A Study in Honor

A Study in Honor reimagines Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson in a near-future America torn apart by a second Civil War. Dr. Janet Watson, a military surgeon who lost her arm in combat, arrives in Washington DC hoping to rebuild her life as a civilian. Watson meets Sara Holmes, a mysterious covert operative who works for a shadowy government agency. The two form an uneasy partnership when they discover soldiers from Watson's former unit are dying under suspicious circumstances. Their investigation leads them through the divided streets of DC, where they confront the intersection of political corruption, advanced technology, and the brutal aftermath of civil conflict. Watson must navigate both her personal trauma and a complex conspiracy while adapting to her temperamental new cybernetic arm. This adaptation explores timeless themes of truth and justice while examining how war reshapes both individual lives and society as a whole. The novel raises questions about loyalty, identity, and the price of serving one's country.

Readers appreciate the fresh take on Sherlock Holmes through a queer Black female lead and the complex friendship between Watson and Holmes. Many note the compelling near-future civil war setting and explorations of PTSD. One reviewer called the world-building "frighteningly plausible." Common criticisms focus on pacing issues, with several readers noting a slow start. Some felt the mystery element was underdeveloped compared to the character focus. A few readers mentioned struggling with the present-tense narration style. Specific praise highlights the authentic medical details and representation of chronic pain. Critics pointed to uneven plot resolution and wanted more development of secondary characters. Ratings: Goodreads: 3.7/5 (1,100+ ratings) Amazon: 4.1/5 (130+ ratings) LibraryThing: 3.8/5 (50+ ratings) "The relationship between Holmes and Watson carries the story" appears in multiple top reviews, while "takes too long to get going" is a frequent critical comment.

A Killing Frost by Seanan McGuire A detective investigates crimes in a future dystopian America where both magical and political forces shape her cases.

The Ruthless Lady's Guide to Wizardry by C.M. Waggoner A queer Victorian-inspired fantasy follows a female bodyguard protecting a noble client while uncovering criminal conspiracies.

The Daughter of Sherlock Holmes by Leonard Goldberg The child of Sherlock Holmes carries on her father's legacy of deduction in a series of intricate mysteries set in early 1900s London.

Ring Shout by P. Djèlí Clark A Black female monster hunter tracks supernatural threats in an alternate 1920s American South where the KKK members transform into demons.

An Unkindness of Ghosts by Rivers Solomon A neurodiverse healer searches for answers about her mother's death aboard a generation ship structured like the antebellum South.

✦ The book reimagines Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson as queer Black women in a near-future America torn apart by civil war ✦ Author Claire O'Dell is a pen name for Beth Bernobich, who has written multiple other science fiction and fantasy novels under her own name ✦ The story incorporates themes of PTSD and trauma recovery, as Dr. Janet Watson deals with both her war injuries and her cybernetic prosthetic arm ✦ The novel won the Lambda Literary Award for LGBTQ Science Fiction/Fantasy/Horror in 2019 ✦ The book is part of a series called "The Janet Watson Chronicles," which continues with "The Hound of Justice," maintaining the tradition of adapting classic Holmes stories into this new setting