Failed Crusade: America and the Tragedy of Post-Communist Russia

Failed Crusade examines U.S. policy toward Russia during the decade following the collapse of the Soviet Union. Cohen analyzes the Clinton administration's approach to Russia's transition and documents what he sees as fundamental misunderstandings of Russian reality by American policymakers and experts. The book presents a critique of American triumphalism and market fundamentalism in the post-Cold War period. Through historical analysis and firsthand observations, Cohen traces how Washington's policies and attitudes affected Russia's development through the 1990s, including the rise of oligarchs and the deterioration of social conditions. Drawing on decades of scholarship in Russian studies, Cohen challenges the prevailing Western narrative about post-Soviet transition. The book includes detailed examination of key events and decisions that shaped U.S.-Russia relations during this critical period. The work stands as both a historical record and a broader commentary on the limits of American power to reshape other societies. Cohen's analysis raises essential questions about cultural understanding, policy assumptions, and the relationship between ideology and foreign policy making.

Readers appreciate Cohen's critique of US policy toward Russia in the 1990s, with many noting his firsthand experience and deep knowledge of the region. Multiple reviews highlight his detailed analysis of how Western "shock therapy" economic policies impacted ordinary Russians. Common praise focuses on: - Clear explanation of complex economic/political transitions - Documentation of living conditions and social upheaval - Analysis of media coverage and public perception Main criticisms: - Some find Cohen too sympathetic to Russian perspectives - A few readers note dated references (book published in 2000) - Several mention repetitive points about market reforms Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (43 ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (28 reviews) Notable reader comment: "Cohen challenges the triumphalist narrative that US policies 'won' the Cold War and shows the human cost of rapid privatization." - Goodreads reviewer Another reader notes: "Essential for understanding why many Russians resent Western influence, though Cohen sometimes overstates his case." - Amazon review

The New Cold War: Putin's Russia and the Threat to the West by Edward Lucas A comprehensive examination of post-Soviet Russia's transformation under Putin's leadership and its deteriorating relationship with Western nations.

Russia: The Story of War by Gregory Carleton An analysis of how warfare shaped Russia's national identity and continues to influence its modern political decisions and global positioning.

Lost Kingdom: The Quest for Empire and the Making of the Russian Nation by Serhii Plokhy A historical account tracking Russia's evolution from its medieval origins through the Soviet collapse and into the present era of nationalism.

The Return of History: Conflict, Migration, and Geopolitics in the Twenty-First Century by Jennifer Welsh An investigation of how post-Cold War assumptions about democracy and globalization failed to materialize in Russia and other nations.

Nothing Is True and Everything Is Possible: The Surreal Heart of the New Russia by Peter Pomerantsev A firsthand account of Russia's post-Soviet transformation through the lens of its media, politics, and business landscape.

📚 Stephen F. Cohen was one of the few Western scholars who consistently challenged the dominant narrative that Russia's post-Soviet transition was a success story, earning him both praise and criticism from fellow academics. 🏛️ The book was published in 2000, just as Vladimir Putin was assuming the presidency of Russia, making its warnings about the fragility of Russian democracy particularly prescient. 💰 Cohen argues that the "shock therapy" economic reforms advocated by Western advisers led to the largest peacetime economic collapse in history, with Russia's GDP falling by nearly 50% in the 1990s. 🗞️ The author served as a consultant for CBS News and appeared regularly on national television, making him one of the most visible American experts on Russian affairs during the crucial post-Soviet period. 🤝 Despite being highly critical of U.S. policy toward Russia, Cohen was married to Katrina vanden Heuvel, publisher of the progressive magazine The Nation, creating an interesting intersection of academic expertise and media influence.