The Way of All Flesh

The Way of All Flesh follows medical apprentice Will Raven in 1847 Edinburgh as he begins working with Dr. James Simpson, a pioneer in the field of obstetrics. When young women start turning up dead across the city, Raven becomes entangled in an investigation while navigating his new role at Simpson's prestigious medical practice. Sarah Fisher, a housemaid in Dr. Simpson's household, possesses a sharp mind and interest in medicine despite the limitations placed on women in Victorian society. As more victims emerge, she and Raven must work together through their mutual distrust to uncover the truth behind the deaths. The novel details a pivotal era in medical history, when doctors first began using chloroform as anesthesia and new scientific methods clashed with traditional practices. The dark streets and medical halls of Victorian Edinburgh serve as the backdrop for this medical thriller. The story explores class divisions, gender roles, and the moral questions that arise when scientific progress challenges established beliefs. Through its examination of medicine's evolution, the novel raises questions about power, knowledge, and who gets to wield them.

Readers highlight the book's vivid portrayal of 1847 Edinburgh's medical world and the compelling mystery elements. Many reviews note the strong chemistry between protagonists Will and Sarah, with several comparing the partnership dynamic to Sherlock Holmes and Watson. Positive reviews focus on: - Historical accuracy and medical details - Fast-moving plot - Complex female characters - Edinburgh atmosphere and setting Common criticisms: - Slow start in first 50 pages - Medical scenes too graphic for some - Plot becomes predictable in places Ratings across platforms: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (2,800+ ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (500+ ratings) BookBrowse: 4.5/5 (80+ ratings) One reader noted: "The medical history feels authentic without overwhelming the story." Another said: "Sarah's character development lifts this above standard historical crime fiction." Critics mentioned "unnecessarily detailed surgical scenes" and "takes too long to build momentum."

The Alienist by Caleb Carr A criminal psychologist and newspaper illustrator track a serial killer through 1896 New York using early forensic methods and psychological profiling.

The Butchering Art by Lindsey Fitzharris This account follows Joseph Lister's mission to transform Victorian medicine and surgery in Edinburgh through germ theory and antiseptic practices.

The Black Death by John Hatcher A reconstruction follows a 14th-century English village through the arrival and impact of the plague, blending historical records with narrative techniques.

The Quincunx by Charles Palliser A young man navigates medical conspiracies and family secrets in Victorian London while uncovering the truth about his inheritance.

The Fatal Shore by Robert Hughes This examination of Australia's convict past reveals medical practices, social conditions, and criminal justice in 18th-century Britain and its penal colonies.

🔍 "The Way of All Flesh" was written by a husband-and-wife duo: consultant anaesthetist Dr. Marisa Haetzman and award-winning author Christopher Brookmyre, writing together under the pen name Ambrose Parry. 💉 The novel is based on real historical events and medical discoveries, particularly the groundbreaking work of Dr. James Young Simpson, who pioneered the use of chloroform as an anaesthetic in Edinburgh during the 1840s. 🏰 The book's atmospheric portrayal of Victorian Edinburgh draws heavily on Dr. Haetzman's research into medical history for her Master's degree, including actual cases from the city's medical records. 🔪 The series of murders in the novel reflects genuine historical concerns about medical experimentation and the ethical questions surrounding early anaesthetic use in the 19th century. 🎭 The character of Sarah Fisher was inspired by the real women who worked as medical assistants during this period but were largely overlooked by history, despite their significant contributions to medical advancement.