What We Left Behind

What We Left Behind follows Toni and Gretchen, high school sweethearts who must navigate their first year apart at different colleges. While Gretchen heads to Boston for school, Toni enrolls at Harvard and begins exploring gender identity in new ways. The story alternates between both characters' perspectives as they face individual challenges and strain in their relationship. Toni becomes immersed in Harvard's LGBTQ community and questions whether identifying as genderqueer still feels right, while Gretchen struggles to find her place at her new school. The novel examines gender, identity, and the evolution of young relationships during major life transitions. Through its dual narrative structure, it presents an intimate look at how people grow both together and apart during times of personal transformation.

Readers note the book's realistic portrayal of college relationships and exploration of gender identity. Many appreciate the dual perspectives between Toni and Gretchen, and the authentic depiction of questioning one's gender. Readers liked: - Raw, honest look at relationship challenges - Educational content about gender terminology - Complex family dynamics - Strong LGBTQ+ representation Main criticisms: - Toni's character comes across as self-absorbed - Relationship drama feels repetitive - Heavy focus on labels and terminology overshadows the story - Some dialogue feels unnatural or preachy One reader said: "The constant misgendering and confusion about pronouns made it hard to follow." Another noted: "Important topics but the execution fell flat." Ratings: Goodreads: 3.2/5 (2,800+ ratings) Amazon: 3.5/5 (50+ reviews) Barnes & Noble: 3/5 (15+ reviews) Common rating description: "Good concept, difficult execution"

If I Was Your Girl by Meredith Russo A transgender teen navigates a new school, romance, and the complexities of identity while protecting her past.

I'll Give You the Sun by Jandy Nelson Twin siblings tell their stories from different timelines as they process art, sexuality, and family relationships.

The Miseducation of Cameron Post by Emily M. Danforth A Montana teenager discovers her sexuality and faces conversion therapy after her conservative aunt becomes her guardian.

Luna by Julie Anne Peters A sister supports her transgender sibling through her transition while dealing with family expectations and societal pressures.

Girl Mans Up by M-E Girard A Portuguese-Canadian teen challenges gender norms and traditional family expectations while exploring identity and relationships.

📚 Author Robin Talley wrote this novel based on her own experiences attending a women's college and her observations of LGBTQ+ identity development during college years. 🎓 The book tackles rarely-discussed topics in YA literature, including the challenges of maintaining a long-distance relationship during the first year of college and the complexities of gender identity exploration. ⏳ Set in 2014, the narrative alternates between past and present timelines, showing how the main characters' relationship evolves over time. 🌈 The novel was one of the first mainstream YA books to feature a genderqueer main character and explore the spectrum of gender identity beyond the binary. 📖 Talley conducted extensive research and consulted with numerous LGBTQ+ individuals during the writing process to ensure authentic representation of diverse gender identities and experiences.