📖 Overview
Twentynine Palms chronicles a 1991 double homicide in the Mojave Desert town near the Marine Corps Air Ground Combat Center. Author Deanne Stillman reconstructs the events leading up to the murders of two teenage girls through interviews, court documents, and deep research into the community.
The book examines the intersection of military culture and civilian life in this remote desert town, where Marines train before deployment. Through her investigation, Stillman documents the lives of the victims, the perpetrator, and the wider social dynamics of a place where young Marines and local residents coexist.
The narrative moves between detailed accounts of the crime and investigation, and broader observations about violence, isolation, and survival in the Mojave Desert. Stillman draws connections between the harsh desert environment and the human events that occur within it.
The work stands as a meditation on American violence and the complex relationships between military bases and their surrounding communities. Through this specific crime, Stillman explores universal themes about power, vulnerability, and the dark corners of American society.
👀 Reviews
Readers found this true crime account haunting and disturbing, praising Stillman's detailed research and atmospheric portrayal of the Mojave Desert setting. Multiple reviews note the author's ability to capture both the desolation of the landscape and the complex social dynamics of a military town.
Readers appreciated:
- Deep exploration of military culture and PTSD
- Rich desert imagery and sense of place
- Thorough investigation and reporting
- Cultural context beyond just the crime
Common criticisms:
- Pacing drags in middle sections
- Too much personal commentary from author
- Excessive focus on desert/environment descriptions
- Some repetitive passages
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.8/5 (500+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.1/5 (100+ reviews)
One reader called it "a devastating portrait of violence and isolation." Another noted it was "less about the crime itself and more about the culture that enabled it." Several reviews mentioned struggling with the brutal subject matter despite the quality of writing.
📚 Similar books
Desert Notes by Barry Lopez
A collection of essays explores the Mojave Desert's impact on human consciousness and behavior through observations of both natural phenomena and human violence.
In Cold Blood by Truman Capote The narrative follows a brutal murder in rural Kansas while examining the psychological states of the killers and the impact on a small community.
The Devil's Highway by Luis Alberto Urrea The book tracks the deadly journey of Mexican migrants through the desert borderlands while weaving together social commentary, landscape, and human desperation.
Dead Girls by Alice Bolin Essays connect true crime narratives, desert mythology, and the American obsession with murdered women in contemporary culture.
Desert Solitaire by Edward Abbey The memoir chronicles life in the Utah desert while examining human relationships with wilderness, violence, and isolation.
In Cold Blood by Truman Capote The narrative follows a brutal murder in rural Kansas while examining the psychological states of the killers and the impact on a small community.
The Devil's Highway by Luis Alberto Urrea The book tracks the deadly journey of Mexican migrants through the desert borderlands while weaving together social commentary, landscape, and human desperation.
Dead Girls by Alice Bolin Essays connect true crime narratives, desert mythology, and the American obsession with murdered women in contemporary culture.
Desert Solitaire by Edward Abbey The memoir chronicles life in the Utah desert while examining human relationships with wilderness, violence, and isolation.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌵 Author Deanne Stillman spent seven years investigating and researching the brutal murders of two young women (Mandi Scott and Rosie Ortega) in the Mojave Desert near the Twentynine Palms Marine Base.
🏜️ The book examines how the military culture, drug use, and isolation of the desert community contributed to an environment where violence against women became more prevalent.
⚔️ The murderer, Valentine Underwood, was a former Marine who had previously been accused of rape but was allowed to remain in service due to insufficient evidence.
📖 The work helped bring attention to domestic violence issues in military communities and was named a "Best Book" by the Los Angeles Times when published in 2001.
🗺️ Twentynine Palms, California, where the events took place, began as a rest stop for gold miners in the 1870s and later became home to one of the largest Marine Corps bases in the world.