Not the Impossible Faith

Not the Impossible Faith systematically examines and responds to claims that Christianity could not have succeeded in the ancient world without divine intervention. The book analyzes social, cultural, and historical factors that influenced Christianity's rise in the Roman Empire. Richard Carrier draws on ancient sources and modern scholarship to investigate ten specific objections to Christianity's natural spread. He examines topics including ancient attitudes toward religion, the role of women in early Christianity, and the appeal of resurrection beliefs in Greco-Roman culture. The book includes detailed discussions of missionary activity, conversion patterns, and the socioeconomic conditions that facilitated religious change in antiquity. The text incorporates archaeological evidence and primary sources to build its historical arguments. This scholarly work contributes to broader debates about religious origins and the interaction between social conditions and spiritual movements. The analysis provides a framework for understanding how new religions gain followers and establish themselves within existing cultural systems.

Readers view this book as a response to Christian apologetics, specifically addressing claims about early Christianity's spread. Many reviewers note its thorough research and citations. Readers highlight: - Clear breakdown of social/cultural context in ancient Rome - Detailed refutation of common apologetic arguments - Accessibility despite academic subject matter Common criticisms: - Repetitive sections - Occasionally combative tone - Some arguments could be more concise Ratings: Goodreads: 4.2/5 (87 ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (46 ratings) One reader noted "Carrier methodically dismantles each claim with historical evidence" while another mentioned "the citations alone make this worth reading." Critical reviews pointed out "the author sometimes gets bogged down explaining basic concepts" and "could have made the same points in half the length." The book appears most popular among readers interested in ancient history and religious studies, with historians praising its academic rigor and laypeople appreciating its readability.

The Case Against Christianity by Michael Martin A systematic examination of the historical and philosophical arguments against core Christian beliefs using academic sources and methodological analysis.

The Early History of God by Mark S. Smith A scholarly investigation of how monotheistic Judaism emerged from polytheistic Canaanite religions through historical and archaeological evidence.

On the Historicity of Jesus by Richard Carrier A peer-reviewed academic analysis applying Bayes' theorem to examine the historical evidence for Jesus' existence.

Christianity in the Light of Science by John W. Loftus A collection of essays from historians and scholars examining Christian claims through scientific methodology and historical investigation.

The Gods of the Ancient Greeks by Robert Graves An examination of how Greek religious beliefs developed and transformed through cultural and historical processes in the ancient Mediterranean world.

🔹 The book was written as a direct response to "The Impossible Faith" by J.P. Holding, challenging his assertion that Christianity could only have succeeded through divine intervention. 🔹 Author Richard Carrier holds a Ph.D. in ancient history from Columbia University and is one of the leading scholars in the academic field of Jesus mythicism. 🔹 The text explores unique sociological aspects of early Christianity, including how the religion gained followers among educated Greeks and Romans despite its origins among lower-class Jews. 🔹 The book examines ancient mystery cults and their similarities to early Christianity, demonstrating how the religious landscape of the Roman Empire was primed for new belief systems. 🔹 Throughout the work, Carrier analyzes primary sources in their original languages (Greek, Latin, and Hebrew), providing new translations and interpretations of key historical texts.