📖 Overview
Enterprising Women is a study of female fan communities who create and share fiction based on media properties like Star Trek and other science fiction shows. The book documents how these writers organize themselves, develop their craft, and build supportive networks.
Bacon-Smith spent multiple years embedded within fan fiction communities, attending conventions and gatherings to understand their social dynamics and creative processes. Her research captures the practices, hierarchies, and mentoring systems that enable fans to develop from novice writers into accomplished creators.
The book examines specific genres within fan fiction, from "hurt-comfort" stories to romantic "slash" fiction, analyzing how different narrative forms serve various emotional and social functions. Through interviews and observation, Bacon-Smith reveals how fans use writing to process personal experiences and build meaningful connections.
This ethnographic work illustrates how marginalized groups can create their own spaces for creative expression and community building outside mainstream channels. The book raises questions about authorship, gender, and the relationship between media consumers and producers.
👀 Reviews
Readers note this as a detailed ethnographic study of female Star Trek fans and fan fiction writers from the 1970s-80s. Several reviewers appreciate Bacon-Smith's immersive research approach and documentation of fan culture during this period.
Likes:
- In-depth look at fan communities before the internet era
- Documentation of slash fiction's early development
- First-hand accounts from participants
Dislikes:
- Some fans feel misrepresented or pathologized
- Writing style called "dry" and "academic"
- Focus limited to specific geographic area/time period
- Methodology questions about sample size and selection
Reader Natalie on Goodreads states: "Important historical document but draws questionable conclusions about fan motivations."
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.7/5 (52 ratings)
Amazon: 4.1/5 (6 ratings)
LibraryThing: 3.8/5 (12 ratings)
Note: Limited online reviews available as book was published in 1992 before widespread internet adoption.
📚 Similar books
Textual Poachers by Henry Jenkins
This ethnographic study explores how fans transform and rewrite media texts through fanfiction, fan art, and other creative practices.
Ink-Stained Amazons and Cinematic Warriors by Jennifer K. Stuller This examination documents the evolution of female heroes in science fiction and their impact on fan communities.
Fan Cultures by Matt Hills This academic analysis investigates the social structures and practices of media fandom from a cultural studies perspective.
The Democratic Genre by Sheenagh Pugh This study explores the mechanics, motivations, and cultural significance of fan fiction writing within online communities.
The Fan Fiction Studies Reader by Karen Hellekson and Kristina Busse This collection presents key academic works on fan fiction and fan communities from the emergence of fan studies through its development as a field.
Ink-Stained Amazons and Cinematic Warriors by Jennifer K. Stuller This examination documents the evolution of female heroes in science fiction and their impact on fan communities.
Fan Cultures by Matt Hills This academic analysis investigates the social structures and practices of media fandom from a cultural studies perspective.
The Democratic Genre by Sheenagh Pugh This study explores the mechanics, motivations, and cultural significance of fan fiction writing within online communities.
The Fan Fiction Studies Reader by Karen Hellekson and Kristina Busse This collection presents key academic works on fan fiction and fan communities from the emergence of fan studies through its development as a field.
🤔 Interesting facts
📚 Author Camille Bacon-Smith spent over five years attending fan conventions and interviewing hundreds of female fans to research this ethnographic study of science fiction fandom.
🖋️ The book was one of the first academic works to seriously examine the role of women in fan fiction communities and their impact on popular culture.
✍️ Bacon-Smith identified specific subgenres within fan fiction, including "hurt/comfort" stories, which she traced to women's traditional roles as caretakers and nurturers.
🌟 The research revealed that many female fans used science fiction and fan communities as a safe space to explore complex social and personal issues that were difficult to address in mainstream society.
📖 Published in 1992, the book helped legitimize fan fiction studies in academia and influenced later scholarly works about participatory fan culture and transformative works.