📖 Overview
An Unexplained Death recounts the true story of Rey Rivera, who was found dead in Baltimore's historic Belvedere Hotel in 2006 under mysterious circumstances. Author Mikita Brottman, who lived in the building at the time, becomes drawn into investigating what happened to Rivera while exploring the hotel's past and examining her own fascination with death.
The narrative follows Brottman's unofficial investigation as she speaks with residents, studies old documents, and pieces together the hotel's history spanning over 100 years. Through her research, she uncovers stories of other deaths and disappearances connected to the Belvedere, while documenting the building's transformation from a luxury hotel to a condominium complex.
Through Rivera's case, Brottman examines broader questions about mortality, the nature of obsession, and humanity's need to find meaning in tragedy. The book combines true crime investigation with memoir and cultural history, creating a meditation on why certain deaths capture our attention and refuse to let go.
👀 Reviews
Readers found the book meandered between true crime investigation, personal memoir, and historical research about the Belvedere building. Many appreciated Brottman's detailed exploration of Rey Rivera's death and her persistence in questioning the official narrative.
Liked:
- Rich historical details about the Belvedere
- Thoughtful exploration of suicide and death
- Writing style and atmosphere
- Author's personal connection to location
Disliked:
- Too much focus on author's personal life
- Lack of resolution or new evidence
- Repetitive sections
- Marketing misleadingly suggests more case details
One reader noted: "The book promises more than it delivers on the investigation front, but offers unexpected depth on death and mortality."
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.5/5 (3,900+ ratings)
Amazon: 3.9/5 (430+ ratings)
LibraryThing: 3.7/5 (90+ ratings)
Several reviewers mentioned expectations of a traditional true crime narrative were not met, but found value in the broader philosophical discussion.
📚 Similar books
I'll Be Gone in the Dark by Michelle McNamara
A writer's obsessive investigation into the Golden State Killer blends true crime with personal narrative while exploring unsolved mysteries and their impact on communities.
The Fact of a Body by Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich The parallel narratives of a murder case and the author's confrontation with childhood trauma intersect in this examination of crime, memory, and justice.
Lost Girls by Robert Kolker The investigation of unsolved murders on Long Island reveals the hidden lives of sex workers and the societal factors that left their cases forgotten.
People Who Eat Darkness by Richard Lloyd Parry The disappearance of a young woman in Tokyo leads to an investigation that uncovers cultural divisions and institutional failures in Japan's criminal justice system.
The Red Parts by Maggie Nelson The reopening of a cold case involving the author's aunt's murder forces a reckoning with family history and the nature of violence.
The Fact of a Body by Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich The parallel narratives of a murder case and the author's confrontation with childhood trauma intersect in this examination of crime, memory, and justice.
Lost Girls by Robert Kolker The investigation of unsolved murders on Long Island reveals the hidden lives of sex workers and the societal factors that left their cases forgotten.
People Who Eat Darkness by Richard Lloyd Parry The disappearance of a young woman in Tokyo leads to an investigation that uncovers cultural divisions and institutional failures in Japan's criminal justice system.
The Red Parts by Maggie Nelson The reopening of a cold case involving the author's aunt's murder forces a reckoning with family history and the nature of violence.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔍 Rey Rivera's mysterious death at the Belvedere Hotel sparked numerous conspiracy theories, including possible connections to his work at a financial newsletter company and cryptic references to the movie "The Game" in his final note.
📚 Author Mikita Brottman lived in the converted Belvedere Hotel for over a decade, giving her unique access and perspective while researching the case.
🏛️ The Belvedere, built in 1903, was once Baltimore's grandest hotel and hosted presidents, celebrities, and literary figures before being converted to apartments in 1976.
💫 The book explores not just Rivera's death but the author's lifelong fascination with death and mortality, influenced by her childhood visits to England's Cottingley Cemetery.
🔎 Brottman conducted extensive interviews with Rey Rivera's widow, Allison, who continues to reject the official ruling of suicide and maintains that key evidence was overlooked in the investigation.