The Religious Question in Modern China

The Religious Question in Modern China examines how Chinese society has grappled with religion from the late Qing dynasty through the present day. The authors trace the dramatic shifts in how religion has been defined, regulated, and practiced across different periods of modern Chinese history. The book analyzes the complex interactions between traditional Chinese religions, imported faiths, and state power during times of radical social transformation. Through extensive research, Goossaert and Palmer explore how modernization efforts impacted religious institutions and beliefs, while documenting the resilience and evolution of spiritual practices in response to political pressure. This scholarly work maps the ongoing tension between secular state authority and religious identity in China's development as a modern nation. The text covers key events and movements that shaped religious policy and practice, from the anti-superstition campaigns to the recent revival of traditional faiths. The work reveals fundamental questions about the role of religion in modernizing societies and the relationship between spiritual traditions and state power. Through its examination of China's religious question, the book offers insights into broader debates about secularization, modernity, and cultural identity.

Scholars and students cite this book's comprehensive analysis of religious transformation in modern China. Readers appreciate the detailed coverage of state-religion dynamics and the authors' examination of how traditional practices evolved through key historical periods. Likes: - Clear breakdown of different religious movements and their societal roles - Documentation of both institutional religion and folk practices - Connection between religion and political developments Dislikes: - Dense academic writing style that some find difficult to follow - Focus on theoretical frameworks over personal accounts - Limited coverage of certain regions and minority faiths One doctoral student noted it "fills crucial gaps in understanding Chinese religious policy evolution." Another reader found it "too theory-heavy with not enough ground-level examples." Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (12 ratings) Amazon: 4.5/5 (6 ratings) Google Books: 4/5 (3 ratings) The book receives more attention in academic citations than consumer reviews, reflecting its scholarly target audience.

The Missionary's Curse and Other Tales from a Chinese Catholic Village by Henrietta Harrison Chronicles the transformation of Chinese Catholicism from the 17th century through modern times through the lens of a single village.

Religion in China: Survival and Revival under Communist Rule by Fenggang Yang Examines the complex relationship between the Chinese state and religious practices from 1949 to the present.

Buddhist Revival in Post-Mao China by Raoul Birnbaum Traces the reconstruction of Buddhist institutions and the revival of Buddhist practice in mainland China after the Cultural Revolution.

Confucianism and Family Rituals in Imperial China by Patricia Buckley Ebrey Analyzes the intersection of state policy, religious practice, and family life in pre-modern China through the study of Confucian rituals.

The Religious State of China by Prasenjit Duara Maps the transformation of Chinese religious life through the lens of state power, modernity, and social change from the late imperial period to the present.

🔹 The book examines a crucial 150-year period (1898-2008) when China transformed from an empire with state-sponsored religion to a secular nation-state, showing how this shift fundamentally altered Chinese society. 🔹 Vincent Goossaert previously served as director of the Groupe Sociétés, Religions, Laïcités at the French National Center for Scientific Research (CNRS), specializing in the study of modern Chinese religion and Taoism. 🔹 The authors reveal how the Chinese Communist Party initially attempted to eliminate religion entirely but later shifted to a policy of "managed religion" - allowing certain approved religious practices while maintaining strict control. 🔹 The book explores how traditional Chinese religious practices seamlessly blended elements of Buddhism, Taoism, and Confucianism - a system that was disrupted by Western concepts of religion and secularism. 🔹 Despite decades of suppression and regulation, by 2008 China had become home to more Christians than Communist Party members, showing the resilience of religious belief in modern Chinese society.