📖 Overview
What Made Maddy Run chronicles the life of Madison Holleran, a University of Pennsylvania freshman and track athlete who struggled with mental health during her transition to college. Through interviews, social media posts, and text messages, journalist Kate Fagan reconstructs Maddy's experiences during her final months.
The book examines the pressures faced by student athletes and the disconnect between social media personas and private struggles. Fagan explores how competitive sports, academic expectations, and the curated world of Instagram intersect in the lives of young people navigating major life changes.
The narrative moves between Maddy's story and broader reporting on college mental health, athlete wellness, and the impact of digital culture on Generation Z. Fagan draws from her own experiences as a college basketball player to provide context for the unique challenges of student athletes.
This investigation raises questions about perfectionism, identity, and the gap between outward achievement and inner turmoil. The book contributes to ongoing discussions about mental health support systems and the evolution of adolescent experiences in the social media age.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe this as a raw, honest examination of mental health struggles in college athletics. Many found the combination of investigative reporting and social media posts effective in showing Maddy's perspective.
Readers appreciated:
- Clear explanations of pressure facing student athletes
- Discussion of social media's impact on mental health
- Balance between Maddy's story and broader context
- Resources and warning signs for depression
Common criticisms:
- Too much focus on the author's own experiences
- Repetitive content in middle sections
- Some felt it sensationalized aspects of the story
Review Scores:
Goodreads: 4.2/5 (13,000+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.6/5 (1,100+ ratings)
"This book helped me understand what my college athlete daughter is going through," noted one Amazon reviewer. A Goodreads user criticized: "The author inserted herself too much into the narrative when this should have been Maddy's story."
📚 Similar books
Girl in Pieces by Elizabeth Glasgow
This story follows a teenage girl's path through self-harm and recovery in a mental health facility, revealing the pressure young women face to maintain a perfect facade.
The Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath The semi-autobiographical account chronicles a college student's descent into mental illness while pursuing academic excellence and navigating societal expectations.
Little & Lion by Brandy Colbert A boarding school student returns home to Los Angeles and confronts mental health challenges within her family while dealing with questions of identity and belonging.
All the Bright Places by Jennifer Niven Two high school students grappling with mental health issues form a connection through a school project about the wonders of Indiana, leading to an exploration of life, death, and healing.
It's Kind of a Funny Story by Ned Vizzini A fifteen-year-old checks himself into a mental health clinic after suicidal thoughts, depicting his five-day stay and the impact of academic pressure on teenage mental health.
The Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath The semi-autobiographical account chronicles a college student's descent into mental illness while pursuing academic excellence and navigating societal expectations.
Little & Lion by Brandy Colbert A boarding school student returns home to Los Angeles and confronts mental health challenges within her family while dealing with questions of identity and belonging.
All the Bright Places by Jennifer Niven Two high school students grappling with mental health issues form a connection through a school project about the wonders of Indiana, leading to an exploration of life, death, and healing.
It's Kind of a Funny Story by Ned Vizzini A fifteen-year-old checks himself into a mental health clinic after suicidal thoughts, depicting his five-day stay and the impact of academic pressure on teenage mental health.
🤔 Interesting facts
🏃♀️ Madison Holleran was a star athlete at the University of Pennsylvania who appeared to have a perfect life on social media, but her Instagram posts masked her struggles with anxiety and depression
📱 Author Kate Fagan chose to explore how social media impacts mental health in college athletes after her article about Madison, "Split Image," became ESPN's most-viewed feature story of 2015
🎯 The book reveals that Division I student-athletes are actually less likely to seek mental health treatment than their non-athlete peers, despite having access to more resources
📚 Madison left behind a suicide note along with gifts for her family, including her favorite Chocolate Chip Mint Luna Bars and the book "Reconstructing Amelia" by Kimberly McCreight
🏆 The story sparked significant changes in collegiate athletics, including the implementation of new mental health screening protocols and support systems at several major universities