📖 Overview
A young child insists that an orange cat in their house is not their family pet. The child provides descriptions and comparisons to prove this is a different feline intruder.
The story follows a simple pattern as the narrator catalogs the differences between their actual pet cat and this mysterious orange visitor. The book's structure builds tension through repetition and observation.
The narrative captures a child's perspective on change and unfamiliarity, exploring themes of perception versus reality. The story demonstrates how young minds process and rationalize unexpected situations.
👀 Reviews
Parents and teachers report this book resonates with young children ages 2-5 who enjoy pointing out and naming objects. The repetitive structure helps emerging readers gain confidence.
Readers appreciate:
- Simple rhyming text that's easy to follow
- Clean illustrations that clearly show what each object is
- Interactive guessing game format
- Humor in the final reveal
- Short length suitable for toddlers
Common criticisms:
- Some find it too basic with limited re-readability
- A few note the concept is similar to other picture books
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.8/5 (129 ratings)
Amazon: 4.6/5 (47 ratings)
Sample reader review: "My 3-year-old loves shouting 'That is not my cat!' on each page. The repetition helped him start recognizing words." - Amazon reviewer
Several classroom teachers mention using it successfully for early literacy activities and vocabulary building with PreK students.
📚 Similar books
This Is Not My Hat by Jon Klassen
A small fish steals a hat and attempts to escape while insisting he won't get caught.
They All Saw A Cat by Brendan Wenzel The story follows a cat walking through its world as different creatures perceive it in distinct ways.
The Bear Ate Your Sandwich by Julia Sarcone-Roach A narrator explains the supposed fate of a missing sandwich through an improbable tale involving a bear.
I Don't Want to Be a Frog by Dev Petty A frog tries to convince his father to let him be anything other than what he is.
No, David! by David Shannon A young boy named David hears "no" throughout his day as he creates various forms of mischief.
They All Saw A Cat by Brendan Wenzel The story follows a cat walking through its world as different creatures perceive it in distinct ways.
The Bear Ate Your Sandwich by Julia Sarcone-Roach A narrator explains the supposed fate of a missing sandwich through an improbable tale involving a bear.
I Don't Want to Be a Frog by Dev Petty A frog tries to convince his father to let him be anything other than what he is.
No, David! by David Shannon A young boy named David hears "no" throughout his day as he creates various forms of mischief.
🤔 Interesting facts
🐱 Author David LaRochelle originally worked as an elementary school teacher for over a decade before becoming a full-time writer and illustrator
🎨 The book uses a clever design where each page reveals a different animal that is mistaken for a cat, building suspense until the final reveal
📚 LaRochelle has won multiple awards for his children's books, including the Sid Fleischman Humor Award and the Minnesota Book Award
🦁 The story playfully explores the concept of animal identification and classification, helping young readers learn to distinguish between different species
🏆 The book's illustrator, Mike Wohnoutka, has collaborated with LaRochelle on several successful children's books, including "Moo!" which won the Minnesota Book Award