📖 Overview
Books Can Be Deceiving introduces Lindsey Norris, the new director of the Briar Creek Public Library in Connecticut. When her best friend Beth's boyfriend is found dead, Lindsey becomes involved in solving the murder to clear Beth's name.
The investigation leads Lindsey through the world of children's book publishing and illustration, where professional rivalries and creative ownership disputes create tension. The small coastal town setting provides both charm and complications as Lindsey navigates local politics and relationships while searching for answers.
The story demonstrates the intersections between creativity, ambition, and ethics in the publishing industry, while exploring themes of friendship and justice. The library setting adds depth to discussions about intellectual property and the value of original work.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe this as a light, comfortable cozy mystery that establishes solid main characters but follows standard genre formulas. The library setting and descriptions of small-town Connecticut appeal to many fans.
Liked:
- Friendship between main characters Lindsey and Beth
- Library atmosphere and book references
- Clean romance without graphic content
- Quick, easy reading pace
Disliked:
- Predictable plot twists
- Some unrealistic character reactions
- Romance feels rushed
- Too many convenient coincidences in solving the mystery
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.8/5 (13,800+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.3/5 (450+ ratings)
Multiple readers noted the book works best for those new to cozy mysteries, with one Goodreads reviewer stating "veterans of the genre will spot the killer immediately." Several Amazon reviewers praised the "charming small-town library setting" but criticized the "by-the-numbers mystery plot that offers few surprises."
📚 Similar books
The Cat in the Stacks by Miranda James
A librarian and his cat solve murders in a small college town while navigating academic politics and library operations.
Murder at the Library by Katie Hickman A reference librarian uncovers connections between rare book thefts and deaths at a historic London library.
The Plot Is Murder by V.M. Burns A mystery bookstore owner writes cozy mysteries while investigating real murders in her Michigan town.
Homicide in Hardback by Kate Carlisle A book restoration expert discovers murder clues hidden in damaged antique books.
Death by the Book by Essie Lang A castle museum curator finds killers through clues left in centuries-old manuscripts and books.
Murder at the Library by Katie Hickman A reference librarian uncovers connections between rare book thefts and deaths at a historic London library.
The Plot Is Murder by V.M. Burns A mystery bookstore owner writes cozy mysteries while investigating real murders in her Michigan town.
Homicide in Hardback by Kate Carlisle A book restoration expert discovers murder clues hidden in damaged antique books.
Death by the Book by Essie Lang A castle museum curator finds killers through clues left in centuries-old manuscripts and books.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔖 Author Jenn McKinlay was a librarian before becoming a full-time writer, lending authenticity to her Library Lover's Mystery series.
📚 The book is set in the fictional coastal town of Briar Creek, Connecticut, inspired by real New England library communities.
🎨 The story features detailed information about children's book illustration and publishing, as protagonist Lindsey's best friend Beth is a children's book illustrator.
📖 This is the first book in the Library Lover's Mystery series, which has grown to include more than 10 installments.
🏆 The series has earned multiple nominations for the Agatha Award, which recognizes excellence in "cozy" mysteries - crime fiction without graphic violence or explicit content.