📖 Overview
Peter Dale Scott examines the historical context and government policies that preceded the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. The book traces decisions and events from the Cold War through multiple presidential administrations, with a focus on U.S. intelligence operations and foreign policy choices.
The analysis covers the evolution of the military-industrial complex, covert operations, and the gradual expansion of executive branch powers. Scott draws connections between past interventions in Afghanistan, changes in intelligence gathering, and shifting relationships with oil-producing nations.
Scott presents documentation from declassified records and government sources to construct his timeline and arguments. The scope encompasses domestic surveillance programs, international banking systems, and the relationships between public and private power structures.
The work raises questions about transparency in governance and the long-term consequences of national security decisions. Through its examination of systemic patterns, the book suggests that historical forces can compound over decades to produce unintended outcomes.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe this as a dense, thoroughly researched examination of the historical policies and decisions that preceded 9/11. Many note it requires careful reading and prior knowledge of US political history.
Positive reviews highlight:
- Documentation and extensive footnotes backing up claims
- Connections drawn between different intelligence agencies and policies
- Analysis of "deep politics" and institutional systems
- Clear explanations of complex government relationships
Common criticisms:
- Writing style is academic and can be difficult to follow
- Too much detail slows the narrative
- Some readers found the scope too broad
- Several reviewers felt conclusions were speculative
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.0/5 (214 ratings)
Amazon: 4.3/5 (38 ratings)
Notable reader comment: "Exhaustively researched but requires real concentration to absorb the intricate web of relationships and events presented." - Goodreads reviewer
Some readers indicated the book works better as a reference text than a straight-through read.
📚 Similar books
The Commission by Philip Shenon
An investigation into the internal workings and conflicts within the 9/11 Commission reveals how political pressures shaped the official report.
Ghost Wars by Steve Coll The history of CIA operations in Afghanistan from 1979-2001 exposes connections between intelligence agencies, terrorist groups, and political decisions.
Legacy of Ashes by Tim Weiner A history of the CIA drawn from primary documents and insider accounts details covert operations and policy decisions that led to major intelligence failures.
The Secret History of the CIA by Joseph Trento Interviews with former CIA officials and declassified documents reveal patterns of intelligence operations and their impact on U.S. foreign policy decisions.
The Looming Tower by Lawrence Wright A chronicle of events leading to 9/11 traces the intersection of intelligence agencies, terrorist organizations, and missed opportunities through examination of primary sources.
Ghost Wars by Steve Coll The history of CIA operations in Afghanistan from 1979-2001 exposes connections between intelligence agencies, terrorist groups, and political decisions.
Legacy of Ashes by Tim Weiner A history of the CIA drawn from primary documents and insider accounts details covert operations and policy decisions that led to major intelligence failures.
The Secret History of the CIA by Joseph Trento Interviews with former CIA officials and declassified documents reveal patterns of intelligence operations and their impact on U.S. foreign policy decisions.
The Looming Tower by Lawrence Wright A chronicle of events leading to 9/11 traces the intersection of intelligence agencies, terrorist organizations, and missed opportunities through examination of primary sources.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔎 Peter Dale Scott coined the term "deep politics" to describe how the visible world of politics is influenced by hidden power networks
📚 The book extensively details Operation Cyclone, the CIA's program to arm the Afghan Mujahideen, which became the agency's largest-ever covert operation
🏛️ Scott's research reveals how the Safari Club, a secret cabal of intelligence agencies, operated outside official channels during the Carter administration
💼 The author served as a Canadian diplomat before becoming a professor at UC Berkeley, where he taught English and deep politics
🔍 The book traces decades of U.S. involvement with al-Qaeda back to the 1979 Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, showing how American allies later became enemies