📖 Overview
John Dee's Conversations with Angels examines the spiritual and occult practices of Elizabeth I's court astrologer and advisor John Dee. The book focuses on Dee's angelic conversations between 1581 and 1585, documented in his private journals.
Through analysis of Dee's manuscripts and historical context, Harkness reconstructs the Renaissance worldview that made angel summoning a legitimate pursuit for a respected scholar. The work situates Dee's practices within the intellectual frameworks of natural philosophy, mathematics, and religious reformation in sixteenth-century England.
Harkness details Dee's collaboration with his scryer Edward Kelley and their use of crystals, mirrors, and ritual objects to facilitate communication with spirits. Their sessions produced complex theological discussions and prophetic messages, recorded in cipher and multiple languages.
The book reveals how Renaissance magic and early modern science were intertwined, challenging modern assumptions about the boundaries between religion, science, and the occult. These angel conversations reflect broader cultural tensions as medieval mysticism gave way to new forms of knowledge and authority.
👀 Reviews
Readers note this academic work offers deep analysis of John Dee's angel conversations through a historical lens rather than an occult one. The research focuses on Dee's role in Elizabethan science and natural philosophy.
Readers appreciated:
- Clear presentation of complex source materials
- Connection of Dee's work to broader Renaissance intellectual trends
- Challenge to the view of Dee as purely an occultist
Common criticisms:
- Dense academic language limits accessibility
- Limited discussion of the actual angel conversations
- High price point for a specialized academic text
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.1/5 (42 ratings)
Amazon: 4.5/5 (12 ratings)
Specific reader feedback:
"Excellent scholarly analysis but requires prior knowledge of the period" - Goodreads reviewer
"More about academic politics than angels" - Amazon reviewer
"The footnotes alone are worth the price" - Academia.edu review
📚 Similar books
The Queen's Conjurer by Benjamin Woolley
This biography examines John Dee's life as Elizabeth I's court astrologer through historical documents and his personal diaries.
Elizabeth's Magician by Glyn Parry The text details Dee's occult practices and political influence through examination of Tudor-era manuscripts and royal court records.
Giordano Bruno and the Hermetic Tradition by Frances A. Yates The book explores Renaissance magic and its influence on early modern intellectuals through analysis of hermetic texts and philosophical writings.
The Arch Conjuror of England by Glyn Parry This work traces John Dee's career through archival research, focusing on his relationship with the Tudor court and his scrying sessions.
Magic in Western Culture by Brian P. Copenhaver The text examines the development of magical thinking from antiquity through the Renaissance with focus on primary sources and historical documentation.
Elizabeth's Magician by Glyn Parry The text details Dee's occult practices and political influence through examination of Tudor-era manuscripts and royal court records.
Giordano Bruno and the Hermetic Tradition by Frances A. Yates The book explores Renaissance magic and its influence on early modern intellectuals through analysis of hermetic texts and philosophical writings.
The Arch Conjuror of England by Glyn Parry This work traces John Dee's career through archival research, focusing on his relationship with the Tudor court and his scrying sessions.
Magic in Western Culture by Brian P. Copenhaver The text examines the development of magical thinking from antiquity through the Renaissance with focus on primary sources and historical documentation.
🤔 Interesting facts
📚 Deborah Harkness is not only a historian but also a best-selling novelist, having written the popular All Souls Trilogy which includes "A Discovery of Witches"
🔮 John Dee's angelic conversations were conducted through a medium named Edward Kelley, who claimed to see and hear angels in a crystal stone
📜 The book draws from Dee's own detailed diaries, which contain over 2,000 pages of recorded angelic conversations spanning from 1581 to 1587
👑 John Dee served as astrologer and scientific advisor to Queen Elizabeth I, and had one of the largest private libraries in Elizabethan England with over 4,000 books
🗝️ The angels supposedly revealed to Dee a special angelic language called "Enochian," which some occultists still study and practice today