📖 Overview
Strange Tribe is John Hemingway's memoir examining three generations of Hemingway men - himself, his father Gregory, and his grandfather Ernest. The book follows their complex family dynamics across decades, focusing particularly on the relationship between Gregory and Ernest.
John Hemingway reconstructs key events through family documents, letters, and personal recollections to understand his father Gregory's struggles with identity and mental health. The narrative moves between time periods, tracing how Ernest Hemingway's legacy and personality influenced both his son Gregory and grandson John.
The story reveals parallels between the three men while exploring themes of masculinity, creativity, and inherited trauma. Through this family portrait, John Hemingway presents a raw examination of what it means to carry the weight of an iconic surname.
👀 Reviews
Readers find the book offers raw insights into the complex Hemingway family dynamics, particularly the relationship between Ernest Hemingway and his son Gregory. Several reviews note the value of getting the family story from an insider's perspective.
Positive comments highlight:
- Candid exploration of mental health issues across generations
- Personal details about Ernest Hemingway not found in other biographies
- Clear writing style that avoids sensationalism
Common criticisms:
- Disjointed narrative structure
- Too much focus on Gregory's later years
- Lack of deeper analysis into key events
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.7/5 (43 ratings)
Amazon: 4.2/5 (21 ratings)
"A brave book that finally tells the truth about Greg Hemingway's struggles" - Amazon reviewer
"The timeline jumps made it hard to follow the story at times" - Goodreads reviewer
"Provides insight into the Hemingway curse of mental illness, but leaves many questions unanswered" - LibraryThing reviewer
📚 Similar books
Papa: A Personal Memoir by Gregory H. Hemingway
The younger son of Ernest Hemingway reveals the complex father-son relationship and family dynamics through personal recollections and experiences.
Growing Up Hemingway by Lorian Hemingway Ernest Hemingway's granddaughter chronicles three generations of the family's struggles with alcoholism, mental illness, and the weight of the Hemingway legacy.
In My Father's Shadow by Chris Welles Feder The daughter of Orson Welles provides insight into life with a brilliant but troubled creative father and the impact of fame on family relationships.
Running with Scissors by Augusten Burroughs A son's memoir details his unconventional upbringing and relationship with his mentally unstable mother through raw family experiences and dark revelations.
The Duke of Deception by Geoffrey Wolff A writer examines his relationship with his con-man father and the impact of family secrets on identity and truth.
Growing Up Hemingway by Lorian Hemingway Ernest Hemingway's granddaughter chronicles three generations of the family's struggles with alcoholism, mental illness, and the weight of the Hemingway legacy.
In My Father's Shadow by Chris Welles Feder The daughter of Orson Welles provides insight into life with a brilliant but troubled creative father and the impact of fame on family relationships.
Running with Scissors by Augusten Burroughs A son's memoir details his unconventional upbringing and relationship with his mentally unstable mother through raw family experiences and dark revelations.
The Duke of Deception by Geoffrey Wolff A writer examines his relationship with his con-man father and the impact of family secrets on identity and truth.
🤔 Interesting facts
📚 Author John Hemingway is Ernest Hemingway's grandson, offering a uniquely personal perspective on the complex family dynamics and mental health struggles that plagued three generations of Hemingway men.
🌟 The book reveals that Gregory Hemingway, John's father and Ernest's youngest son, struggled with gender identity issues throughout his life and occasionally lived as a woman named Gloria.
💫 "Strange Tribe" explores how both Ernest and Gregory Hemingway were talented writers and physicians - Gregory was a licensed medical doctor before his personal struggles derailed his career.
✨ The memoir connects Ernest Hemingway's famous machismo to a family pattern of overcompensation, suggesting that both father and son felt compelled to prove their masculinity through exaggerated behaviors.
🎯 The book's title comes from Ernest Hemingway's own description of his family as a "strange tribe" in a letter to his publisher Charles Scribner.