📖 Overview
Eve L. Ewing examines the 2013 mass closure of 49 Chicago public schools through research, interviews, and personal accounts. Her investigation focuses on three schools in Chicago's Bronzeville neighborhood and chronicles the community's response to the closures.
As a former Chicago Public Schools teacher and Bronzeville resident, Ewing brings an insider's perspective to the conflict between city officials and local residents. She documents public hearings, protests, and conversations with students, parents, and educators affected by the school closures.
Through historical analysis, Ewing traces the roots of educational inequality in Chicago's Black communities from the Great Migration through contemporary policy decisions. She explores how schools function as community anchors and how their closure impacts neighborhood identity and stability.
The book confronts questions of race, power, and institutional racism in urban education policy while highlighting the deep connections between schools and their communities. Ewing's work challenges readers to consider whose voices matter in decisions about public education and community development.
👀 Reviews
Readers appreciate Ewing's personal connection to Chicago's school closures and her methodical analysis combining data with community voices. Many note her effective use of historical context to explain why residents fought to keep underperforming schools open.
Common praise focuses on Ewing's clear writing style making complex policy issues accessible. Several reviews highlight her balanced presentation of different perspectives while centering the community's lived experiences.
Critics say the book could have explored more solutions or alternative approaches to failing schools. Some readers wanted more comparative analysis with school closures in other cities.
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.47/5 (1,200+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.8/5 (165 ratings)
Sample review quotes:
"Explains the deep meaning schools hold in communities beyond test scores" - Goodreads reviewer
"Would have benefited from examining successful school turnaround cases" - Amazon reviewer
"Made me rethink assumptions about 'failing' schools" - BookRiot review
📚 Similar books
The Death and Life of the Great American School System by Diane Ravitch
This examination of education reform in America traces how testing, choice, and privatization movements have affected urban public schools and communities.
Despite the Best Intentions by John Diamond, Amanda Lewis The book documents how racial inequalities persist in schools through institutional practices, disciplinary patterns, and tracking systems.
Savage Inequalities by Jonathan Kozol Through visits to schools across America, this investigation exposes the disparities between affluent and poor districts and their impact on students, teachers, and communities.
The Price of Nice by Angelina Castagno This analysis reveals how the pursuit of niceness in educational settings masks and perpetuates racial inequities in Chicago schools.
Cutting School by Noliwe Rooks This historical study connects contemporary school segregation to past practices of systemic inequality in American education.
Despite the Best Intentions by John Diamond, Amanda Lewis The book documents how racial inequalities persist in schools through institutional practices, disciplinary patterns, and tracking systems.
Savage Inequalities by Jonathan Kozol Through visits to schools across America, this investigation exposes the disparities between affluent and poor districts and their impact on students, teachers, and communities.
The Price of Nice by Angelina Castagno This analysis reveals how the pursuit of niceness in educational settings masks and perpetuates racial inequities in Chicago schools.
Cutting School by Noliwe Rooks This historical study connects contemporary school segregation to past practices of systemic inequality in American education.
🤔 Interesting facts
📚 The book examines Chicago's 2013 mass school closure that targeted 49 public schools, primarily in Black neighborhoods, through both data analysis and personal narratives.
🎓 Eve L. Ewing, besides being a sociologist and writer, is also a former Chicago Public Schools teacher who taught at one of the schools discussed in the book.
🏆 The book's title comes from a question Ewing posed: "If a school is more than a school, what does it mean for a school to die?" exploring how closed schools continue to "haunt" their communities.
📝 Ewing uses innovative mixed methodology, combining traditional academic research with poetry, oral histories, and archival documents to tell the story of these school closures.
🗣️ The research heavily features the voices of students, parents, and community members who were directly affected by the closures, providing perspectives often missing from policy discussions about education reform.