📖 Overview
Greta James is an indie musician facing a career crisis after a public meltdown following her mother's death. When she agrees to join her father on an Alaskan cruise that was meant to be her parents' 40th anniversary trip, she must confront both her grief and their strained relationship.
The week-long voyage through the Inside Passage forces Greta and her father Conrad, a practical-minded investment advisor, to address their different views on art, ambition, and risk-taking. Their time at sea is complicated by the presence of Ben, a history professor who catches Greta's attention, and the other passengers who recognize her from her viral onstage breakdown.
During the cruise's stops in various Alaskan ports, Greta grapples with whether to continue her music career while navigating family expectations and personal doubt. The novel examines themes of parent-child relationships, artistic passion, and the challenge of charting one's own course while honoring family bonds.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe this book as a contemplative story about grief, family relationships, and finding one's path. Many note it works better as a character study than a romance.
Readers appreciated:
- Authentic portrayal of parent-child tension
- Vivid Alaskan cruise setting details
- Musical elements and indie rock references
- Complex father-daughter dynamics
- Audio narration by Julia Whelan
Common criticisms:
- Slow pacing, especially in middle sections
- Romance subplot feels underdeveloped
- Some found Greta's character frustrating
- Ending left questions unresolved
Review Scores:
Goodreads: 3.9/5 (44,000+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.2/5 (2,800+ ratings)
BookPage: 4/5
Sample reader comment: "The family dynamics hit close to home. While marketed as a romance, this is really about a daughter and father learning to understand each other." -Goodreads reviewer
"Beautiful writing but moves too slowly. Expected more from the romantic storyline." -Amazon reviewer
📚 Similar books
Daisy Jones & The Six by Taylor Jenkins Reid
This novel chronicles the rise and fall of a 1970s rock band through interviews and memories, exploring the costs of fame and the complex relationships between musicians.
The Music of Bees by Eileen Garvin Three broken people find healing and connection through beekeeping in Oregon while processing grief and building new dreams.
The Storyteller by Dave Grohl A memoir traces the path from a suburban kid to a global rock star, examining the relationship between parents, children, and the pull of music.
Florence Gordon by Brian Morton A feminist icon grapples with family obligations and personal ambitions while trying to write her memoir in New York City.
Songs in Ursa Major by Emma Brodie A female musician in the 1960s navigates love, artistic integrity, and industry demands during her rise to fame on an island off the coast of Massachusetts.
The Music of Bees by Eileen Garvin Three broken people find healing and connection through beekeeping in Oregon while processing grief and building new dreams.
The Storyteller by Dave Grohl A memoir traces the path from a suburban kid to a global rock star, examining the relationship between parents, children, and the pull of music.
Florence Gordon by Brian Morton A feminist icon grapples with family obligations and personal ambitions while trying to write her memoir in New York City.
Songs in Ursa Major by Emma Brodie A female musician in the 1960s navigates love, artistic integrity, and industry demands during her rise to fame on an island off the coast of Massachusetts.
🤔 Interesting facts
🎸 While Greta James is a fictional indie rock musician, author Jennifer E. Smith drew inspiration from real female indie artists like Patti Smith and Sharon Van Etten to create an authentic portrayal of the music scene.
🚢 The Alaskan cruise setting was based on the author's own experience taking an Alaskan cruise with her father, though their relationship was much warmer than Greta's complicated bond with her dad.
📚 This was Jennifer E. Smith's first adult novel after establishing herself as a successful YA author with books like "The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight" and "Hello, Goodbye, and Everything in Between."
🎼 The book's exploration of grief through music was partially influenced by Smith watching musicians like Nick Cave and David Bowie process their losses through their art.
🏆 The novel was selected as a Read with Jenna Book Club Pick by Jenna Bush Hager in March 2022, helping it reach a wider audience and sparking discussions about parent-child relationships and pursuing artistic dreams.