📖 Overview
David Currie documents his religious transformation from an evangelical Protestant minister to a Catholic convert. His memoir traces his early years in a fundamentalist family and his path through Protestant seminary training.
The book presents biblical analysis, historical research, and theological questions that arose during Currie's spiritual journey. He examines core doctrinal differences between Protestant and Catholic beliefs, including interpretations of scripture, church authority, and sacramental theology.
The narrative includes Currie's experiences wrestling with changes in his faith while serving as a Protestant minister and teacher. His account involves both personal reflection and academic investigation of Catholic and Protestant traditions.
This work contributes to broader discussions about Christian unity, denominational differences, and the role of tradition in religious faith. The text serves as both a personal testimony and a theological exploration of Protestant-Catholic relations.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe this as a thoughtful explanation of one person's journey from Protestant fundamentalism to Catholicism. Many note its clear presentation of Catholic teachings and systematic addressing of Protestant objections through Scripture and historical sources.
Positive feedback:
- Thorough research and biblical citations
- Respectful tone toward both faiths
- Personal narrative makes theological concepts accessible
- Helpful for those questioning their faith tradition
Common criticisms:
- Too academic/dense for casual readers
- Some argue certain Protestant views are oversimplified
- A few readers found the writing style dry
Ratings:
Amazon: 4.6/5 from 298 reviews
Goodreads: 4.1/5 from 683 ratings
Sample review: "As a former Protestant minister, I found Currie's Biblical analysis compelling, though I wished for more emotional depth in parts." - Amazon reviewer
"The historical evidence presented made me reconsider long-held assumptions about early church teaching." - Goodreads reviewer
📚 Similar books
Rome Sweet Home by Scott Hahn, Kimberly Hahn
The conversion story of Presbyterian minister Scott Hahn and his wife to Catholicism through biblical and theological study.
Crossing the Tiber by Stephen K. Ray A software company owner documents his family's journey from evangelical Protestantism to Catholicism through examination of church history and the early church fathers.
By What Authority? by Mark P. Shea A former evangelical's investigation of sola scriptura leads to discoveries about Catholic teaching authority and sacred tradition.
The Catholic Church and Conversion by G.K. Chesterton The renowned British writer charts his intellectual path from agnosticism to Anglicanism to Catholicism through philosophical reasoning.
Not Peace but a Sword by Robert Hugh Benson An Anglican priest and son of the Archbishop of Canterbury describes his conversion to Catholicism through doctrinal study and prayer.
Crossing the Tiber by Stephen K. Ray A software company owner documents his family's journey from evangelical Protestantism to Catholicism through examination of church history and the early church fathers.
By What Authority? by Mark P. Shea A former evangelical's investigation of sola scriptura leads to discoveries about Catholic teaching authority and sacred tradition.
The Catholic Church and Conversion by G.K. Chesterton The renowned British writer charts his intellectual path from agnosticism to Anglicanism to Catholicism through philosophical reasoning.
Not Peace but a Sword by Robert Hugh Benson An Anglican priest and son of the Archbishop of Canterbury describes his conversion to Catholicism through doctrinal study and prayer.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔹 David Currie was raised in a devout Christian home where his father was a fundamentalist preacher, and he himself planned to become a minister before his journey to Catholicism.
🔹 The book details Currie's seven-year intellectual and spiritual journey, during which he read over 500 books on theology, church history, and religious topics before making his decision to convert.
🔹 The author's conversion to Catholicism led to significant family tensions, particularly with his father, though they eventually reconciled while maintaining their different beliefs.
🔹 The text specifically addresses 35 key questions about Catholic teachings that typically concern Protestant believers, including topics like papal infallibility, Marian devotion, and the Real Presence in the Eucharist.
🔹 Published in 1996, this book has become a significant work in the modern Catholic conversion narrative genre, alongside others like Scott Hahn's "Rome Sweet Home" and Stephen Ray's "Crossing the Tiber."