📖 Overview
Tribute to Freud presents H.D.'s memoir of her sessions with Sigmund Freud in Vienna during 1933-1934. The poet and novelist records her experiences as both a patient and student of psychoanalysis during a period of mounting political tension in Europe.
The text combines elements of biography, autobiography, and dream analysis through a non-linear narrative structure. H.D. documents her conversations with Freud, her impressions of his office and methods, and her own psychological journey.
Through free association and memory, H.D. explores her wartime experiences, artistic development, and complex relationship dynamics. The sessions focus on her visions, dreams, and writing process as they intersect with Freud's analytical framework.
The memoir stands as both a testament to Freud's impact on modernist literature and an exploration of the connection between psychoanalysis and artistic creation. The work raises questions about memory, trauma, and the role of the unconscious in creative expression.
👀 Reviews
Readers view this as an intimate, personal account rather than a scholarly text about psychoanalysis. The book maintains a 3.9/5 rating on Goodreads from 170+ ratings.
Readers appreciate:
- The poetic, dreamlike writing style that mirrors the psychoanalytic process
- H.D.'s candid descriptions of her sessions with Freud
- The humanizing portrayal of Freud as both doctor and person
- The historical value of documenting pre-WWII Vienna
Common criticisms:
- Nonlinear structure makes the narrative hard to follow
- Too much focus on H.D.'s personal experiences rather than Freud's methods
- Writing style can be overly abstract and meandering
As one Goodreads reviewer notes: "Beautiful prose but requires patience to piece together the fragments." Another writes: "More a memoir of their relationship than an examination of his theories."
Amazon reviews (3.8/5 from 12 ratings) echo these sentiments, with several mentioning the book works better as a personal reflection than an academic resource.
📚 Similar books
Memories, Dreams, Reflections by Carl Jung, Aniela Jaffé
A psychoanalyst's memoir combines personal revelations with explorations of the unconscious mind through dreams and visions.
The Life and Work of Sigmund Freud by Ernest Jones This biographical account presents Freud's development of psychoanalysis through his personal experiences and professional relationships.
Writing and Madness by Hélène Cixous The text weaves psychoanalytic theory with literary criticism while examining the intersection of creativity and psychological states.
H.D. and Freud: Biography and Psychoanalysis by Susan Stanford Friedman This study examines H.D.'s relationship with Freud through letters, manuscripts, and analysis sessions.
A Woman Looking at Men Looking at Women by Siri Hustvedt The book connects psychoanalysis, art, and feminism through essays that explore the mind-body connection and human consciousness.
The Life and Work of Sigmund Freud by Ernest Jones This biographical account presents Freud's development of psychoanalysis through his personal experiences and professional relationships.
Writing and Madness by Hélène Cixous The text weaves psychoanalytic theory with literary criticism while examining the intersection of creativity and psychological states.
H.D. and Freud: Biography and Psychoanalysis by Susan Stanford Friedman This study examines H.D.'s relationship with Freud through letters, manuscripts, and analysis sessions.
A Woman Looking at Men Looking at Women by Siri Hustvedt The book connects psychoanalysis, art, and feminism through essays that explore the mind-body connection and human consciousness.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 H.D. (Hilda Doolittle) underwent psychoanalysis with Sigmund Freud in Vienna during 1933-1934, just as the Nazi threat was growing in Europe. Freud would later flee to London in 1938.
📚 The book was originally published in two parts: "Writing on the Wall" in 1944 and "Advent" in 1956, before being combined into a single volume.
🎭 During her sessions, H.D. and Freud often discussed ancient mythology and symbolism, connecting her poetic visions with psychoanalytic theory - a unique intersection of modernist poetry and psychological analysis.
✍️ H.D.'s account differs from traditional patient memoirs by focusing on Freud as a person rather than on her treatment, painting him as a grandfather-like figure she called "the Professor."
🖼️ The book's title "Writing on the Wall" refers to H.D.'s vivid hallucination of Greek letters appearing on a hotel wall in Corfu - an experience Freud helped her interpret through their sessions.