Highbrow/Lowbrow: The Emergence of Cultural Hierarchy in America

Lawrence Levine's Highbrow/Lowbrow examines the transformation of American cultural categories between 1850-1900. The book focuses on how Shakespeare, opera, museums, and symphonic music shifted from popular entertainment to elite culture during this period. Through extensive historical documentation and cultural analysis, Levine traces how these art forms were originally enjoyed by diverse American audiences across social classes. He documents the gradual process by which cultural gatekeepers and institutions began separating "serious" art from popular entertainment. The study looks closely at specific venues, performances, and audience behaviors to demonstrate how cultural hierarchies were actively constructed rather than naturally occurring. Cases include the evolution of concert hall etiquette, museum display practices, and changing interpretations of Shakespeare's works. This work challenges assumptions about inherent cultural divisions and reveals how social forces shape what society considers "high" versus "low" art. The book's examination of cultural segregation provides insights into broader questions about power, class, and access to the arts in America.

Readers credit this book with explaining how American cultural categories evolved, particularly how Shakespeare and classical music transformed from popular entertainment into high culture. Many note its clear documentation of 19th century cultural shifts. Positive reviews highlight: - Strong research and historical evidence - Accessible writing style for an academic work - Fresh perspective on cultural segregation Common criticisms: - Repetitive arguments - Focus too narrow on Shakespeare/opera examples - Some readers wanted more analysis of modern implications Ratings: Goodreads: 4.0/5 (392 ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (31 ratings) Sample reader comments: "Made me rethink assumptions about high vs low culture" - Goodreads reviewer "Gets bogged down in theatrical details" - Amazon reviewer "Changed how I view cultural hierarchies but could be more concise" - JSTOR review Most academic readers recommend it for cultural history studies, while general readers find the theatrical focus too specialized.

Cities of Knowledge by Margaret O'Mara This study traces how Cold War politics and federal funding transformed American universities and reshaped cultural hierarchies in higher education between 1940-1970.

The Great Art of Light and Shadow by Laurent Mannoni The book examines the transformation of magic lantern shows from popular entertainment to high art, revealing class-based distinctions in visual culture.

Sacred Spaces by Lawrence W. Levine The analysis explores how American museums evolved from public educational spaces into temples of elite culture during the nineteenth century.

Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgment of Taste by Pierre Bourdieu This sociological examination demonstrates how cultural tastes and preferences function as markers of class position and social power.

The Temple and the Forum by David Levine The work chronicles the shift in American theater from democratic entertainment to high culture through the lens of Shakespeare performances from 1800-1900.

🎭 Prior to the late 1800s, Shakespeare plays were popular entertainment for all social classes in America, often performed in rowdy theaters where audiences would eat, drink, and vocally interact with the performers. 📚 Author Lawrence Levine won the 1990 John Hope Franklin Prize from the American Studies Association for this groundbreaking work on cultural hierarchy. 🎪 During the 19th century, many American theaters would present a mix of entertainment in a single evening—combining opera, circus acts, melodrama, and minstrel shows—rather than focusing on a single art form. 🎵 The Boston Symphony Orchestra, now considered the epitome of highbrow culture, originally included popular music and light classics in its programs until the early 20th century. 🎨 The book demonstrates how museums, which were once boisterous public spaces where working-class families gathered for entertainment and education, were deliberately transformed into quiet, reverential spaces to create social distinctions.