📖 Overview
Holland Bakker encounters a talented subway musician during her daily commute in New York City. Though initially too shy to speak to him, circumstances bring them together when Holland learns he could be the perfect candidate for her uncle's Broadway musical.
Calvin McLoughlin, an Irish guitarist, faces immigration issues that prevent him from pursuing his music career. Holland proposes a marriage of convenience that would allow him to accept the Broadway position and stay in the United States legally.
Their arrangement forces them to maintain appearances while navigating their complex feelings and professional ambitions. They must balance their growing connection with the risks and consequences of their unconventional situation.
The story explores themes of authenticity, sacrifice, and the blurred lines between genuine connection and pragmatic choices. Through its examination of art, immigration, and relationships, the novel raises questions about what people will do for love, music, and the chance to follow their dreams.
👀 Reviews
Readers call this a fun, light romance with an engaging dynamic between Holland and Calvin. Many mention reading it in one sitting.
Readers appreciated:
- The realistic portrayal of New York City arts/music scene
- Strong character development beyond the central romance
- Humor and witty dialogue
- Dual perspectives that show both characters' growth
Common criticisms:
- Predictable plot progression
- Some found Holland naive and impulsive
- Several readers wanted more development of secondary characters
- The marriage-of-convenience premise felt forced to some
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.9/5 (87,800+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.4/5 (1,900+ ratings)
Barnes & Noble: 4.3/5 (300+ ratings)
Review quotes:
"The musical elements add depth beyond typical romance tropes" - Goodreads reviewer
"Holland's career struggles felt authentic but her decisions were frustrating" - Amazon reviewer
"Great chemistry but needed more complexity in the supporting cast" - Barnes & Noble reviewer
📚 Similar books
The Spanish Love Deception by Elena Armas
A woman convinces her work nemesis to pose as her boyfriend at her sister's Spanish wedding, leading to a slow-burn romance filled with forced proximity and cultural clashes.
The Friend Zone by Abby Jimenez A wedding planner and a firefighter navigate their growing feelings while dealing with a medical condition that threatens their future together.
Beach Read by Emily Henry Two writers with opposing genres switch writing styles for a summer and discover connection through their creative process and personal healing.
The Marriage Game by Sara Desai An career-focused woman shares an office space with a recruitment consultant, resulting in a competition that transforms into an unexpected romance.
The Flatshare by Beth O'Leary Two strangers share a one-bedroom apartment on opposite schedules, developing a relationship through notes before meeting in person.
The Friend Zone by Abby Jimenez A wedding planner and a firefighter navigate their growing feelings while dealing with a medical condition that threatens their future together.
Beach Read by Emily Henry Two writers with opposing genres switch writing styles for a summer and discover connection through their creative process and personal healing.
The Marriage Game by Sara Desai An career-focused woman shares an office space with a recruitment consultant, resulting in a competition that transforms into an unexpected romance.
The Flatshare by Beth O'Leary Two strangers share a one-bedroom apartment on opposite schedules, developing a relationship through notes before meeting in person.
🤔 Interesting facts
🎵 Christina Lauren is actually a pen name for two best friends and writing partners - Christina Hobbs and Lauren Billings - who have co-written numerous bestselling romance novels together.
🎭 The musical aspects of the book were inspired by real Broadway shows, particularly "Once" and "Spring Awakening," which helped shape the authentic feel of the theatrical elements.
🗽 The novel's depiction of the New York City subway system, where Holland and Calvin first meet, is based on actual subway musicians who perform in the stations through the MTA's "Music Under New York" program.
💑 The authors wrote Holland and Calvin's story during a period of significant success in their careers, following their Beautiful Bastard series, which had already established them as major voices in contemporary romance.
🌟 The book tackles real issues faced by immigrant artists in America, including visa complications and the challenges of pursuing artistic careers while maintaining legal status - a topic rarely explored in contemporary romance novels.