📖 Overview
Mad, Bad, Dangerous to Know examines the relationships between three major Irish writers - Oscar Wilde, W.B. Yeats, and James Joyce - and their fathers. Tóibín traces the lives of William Wilde, John Butler Yeats, and John Stanislaus Joyce in Dublin during the late nineteenth century.
The book emerged from Tóibín's lectures at Emory University and combines biography, literary criticism, and cultural history. Through letters, documents, and works by the writers themselves, Tóibín reconstructs the complex father-son dynamics that influenced these literary figures.
The parallel narratives follow the decline of these patriarchs - from their early promise through financial troubles and social scandals. The text highlights how their sons transformed aspects of their fathers' lives into art.
The book reveals patterns in how children of troubled fathers channel difficult inheritance into creative work. Its exploration of Dublin's cultural landscape shows how place and lineage shape artistic development.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe this as an intimate look at the fathers of Wilde, Yeats, and Joyce, though many note it feels more like connected essays than a cohesive narrative.
Readers appreciated:
- Deep research into historical Dublin
- The focus on lesser-known family dynamics
- Writing style that brings historical figures to life
- Fresh perspective on familiar literary figures
Common criticisms:
- Too academic and dry for general readers
- Loose connections between the three narratives
- Too much focus on Dublin social history versus the fathers themselves
"The book meanders through tangential details" appears in multiple reviews. Several readers noted they expected more direct connections to how these fathers influenced their sons' writing.
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.7/5 (1,100+ ratings)
Amazon: 4/5 (90+ ratings)
LibraryThing: 3.8/5 (50+ ratings)
The title attracts readers expecting dramatic family stories, but reviewers say it's better suited for those interested in Irish literary history.
📚 Similar books
Fathers and Sons by Edmund White
A memoir exploring the complex relationships between literary figures and their fathers, focusing on writers including Vladimir Nabokov and Albert Camus.
On Writers and Writing by Margaret Atwood An examination of the lives, influences, and personal struggles of writers through history, with focus on parent-child dynamics and artistic development.
Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man by James Joyce A semi-autobiographical novel detailing an Irish artist's relationship with his father while navigating Dublin's literary and social landscape.
The Trip to Echo Spring by Olivia Laing A study of six writers including Tennessee Williams and Ernest Hemingway, examining their relationships with family and the impact on their work.
My Father's Life by Raymond Carver A collection of biographical essays exploring the father-son relationship through the lens of literary figures and their personal histories.
On Writers and Writing by Margaret Atwood An examination of the lives, influences, and personal struggles of writers through history, with focus on parent-child dynamics and artistic development.
Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man by James Joyce A semi-autobiographical novel detailing an Irish artist's relationship with his father while navigating Dublin's literary and social landscape.
The Trip to Echo Spring by Olivia Laing A study of six writers including Tennessee Williams and Ernest Hemingway, examining their relationships with family and the impact on their work.
My Father's Life by Raymond Carver A collection of biographical essays exploring the father-son relationship through the lens of literary figures and their personal histories.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔹 The book explores the lives of three famous Irish literary fathers: John Stanislaus Joyce (father of James Joyce), William Wilde (father of Oscar Wilde), and John Butler Yeats (father of W.B. Yeats), examining how their complex relationships influenced their sons' writings.
🔹 Author Colm Tóibín initially developed these stories as part of the Richard Ellmann Lectures at Emory University, named after the celebrated biographer of both James Joyce and Oscar Wilde.
🔹 While researching the book, Tóibín regularly walked the same Dublin streets where these fathers and sons lived, creating a personal mapping of their lives that weaves throughout the narrative.
🔹 William Wilde, before becoming Oscar's father, was a renowned eye and ear surgeon who wrote several medical texts and established his own hospital in Dublin at age 28.
🔹 John Butler Yeats abandoned his legal career to become a painter and spent the last 15 years of his life in New York, corresponding with his son W.B. Yeats through letters but never returning to Ireland.