📖 Overview
Two teens from opposite sides of their small Washington state town form an unlikely connection. Billy Sloat comes from a poor, unstable background while Lydia Lemon presents a relentlessly optimistic front despite her own difficult circumstances.
The town of Fogmouth is caught between the collapse of its fishing industry and the rise of a corporate presence tied to Lydia's family. As Billy and Lydia's lives intersect, strange events begin occurring - including increasingly severe weather and mysterious phenomena that blur the line between reality and fantasy.
Their growing friendship becomes a lifeline as both teens navigate family secrets, local legends, and escalating chaos in their community. The story combines elements of magical realism with grounded explorations of class divisions, family dynamics, and small-town American life.
The novel examines how hope and human connection can persist even as familiar worlds seem to crumble, while questioning the stories we tell ourselves about our communities and our past.
👀 Reviews
Readers call this book a surreal blend of magical realism and contemporary issues. Many note the unique narrative style that alternates between protagonists Billy and Lydia.
Positive reviews highlight:
- Raw, honest portrayal of trauma and difficult family dynamics
- Strong character development and emotional depth
- Creative use of magical elements to represent mental health
- Impactful messages about hope and friendship
Common criticisms:
- Pacing feels uneven, especially in middle sections
- Some found the metaphors and symbolism heavy-handed
- Several readers struggled with the more abstract elements
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.7/5 (900+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.1/5 (50+ ratings)
"The writing pulled me in completely but the supernatural elements felt forced," noted one Goodreads reviewer. Another wrote, "Powerful commentary on small town life and generational trauma, even if the magical parts didn't always land."
The book resonates most strongly with readers who appreciate experimental YA fiction that tackles serious themes.
📚 Similar books
We Are Okay by Nina LaCour
A quiet exploration of grief and isolation follows a teen who must confront her past relationships and family trauma.
A Song Below Water by Bethany C. Morrow Two best friends navigate magical powers and social injustice in a world where sirens exist alongside everyday discrimination.
The Strange and Beautiful Sorrows of Ava Lavender by Leslye Walton This generational tale weaves magical realism with family histories through the story of a girl born with wings.
I'll Give You the Sun by Jandy Nelson Twin artists tell their story from different timelines as they unravel family secrets and process loss through their art.
When the Moon Was Ours by Anna-Marie McLemore Two teens bound by secrets and roses face their identities and relationships in a town touched by magic.
A Song Below Water by Bethany C. Morrow Two best friends navigate magical powers and social injustice in a world where sirens exist alongside everyday discrimination.
The Strange and Beautiful Sorrows of Ava Lavender by Leslye Walton This generational tale weaves magical realism with family histories through the story of a girl born with wings.
I'll Give You the Sun by Jandy Nelson Twin artists tell their story from different timelines as they unravel family secrets and process loss through their art.
When the Moon Was Ours by Anna-Marie McLemore Two teens bound by secrets and roses face their identities and relationships in a town touched by magic.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 Amy Reed wrote this book while living in a small town in Washington state, which became part of her inspiration for the story's setting
🌈 The novel blends magical realism with contemporary issues, exploring themes of friendship, family trauma, and the power of believing in oneself
🎭 The two main characters, Billy and Lydia, represent opposite approaches to life - one an optimist despite difficult circumstances, the other a pessimist despite privilege
🌪️ Weather phenomena play a crucial role in the story, with increasingly surreal climate events mirroring the characters' emotional journeys
📚 The book was published in 2019 by Simon Pulse, an imprint known for publishing thought-provoking young adult literature that tackles complex social issues