Twice Shy

Maybell Parish inherits a mansion in the Tennessee mountains from her great-aunt, only to discover she must share ownership with Wesley Koehler, a grouchy groundskeeper. The inheritance comes with specific conditions that force these two socially anxious people to interact and make joint decisions about the property. Both Maybell and Wesley struggle with communication, though in different ways. While Maybell retreats into daydreams and romantic fantasies, Wesley maintains rigid schedules and communicates through carefully written notes, avoiding face-to-face conversations whenever possible. As they navigate the challenges of co-ownership, Maybell and Wesley must confront their fears, past experiences, and misconceptions about each other. Their efforts to restore the old mansion parallel their journey to overcome personal barriers. The novel explores themes of healing from past hurts and finding authentic connection despite social anxiety and communication differences. Through its romance framework, the story examines how people build trust and understanding when traditional modes of interaction feel impossible.

Readers describe a slow-burn romance focused on anxiety, healing from past trauma, and finding love despite emotional barriers. Readers highlight: - Realistic portrayal of social anxiety and panic attacks - Character growth and communication between leads - The scavenger hunt plot device - Sweet, low-conflict romance without manufactured drama - Humor balanced with emotional depth Common criticisms: - Very slow pacing in first third - Some found the anxiety representation overwhelming - Limited physical chemistry between characters - Plot can feel repetitive Ratings across platforms: Goodreads: 3.9/5 (47,000+ ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (2,800+ ratings) StoryGraph: 3.9/5 Sample reader quote: "Finally a romance novel that doesn't treat anxiety as a quirky personality trait but shows the daily reality of living with it." - Goodreads reviewer "The emotional journey resonates but the romantic development needed more spark." - Amazon reviewer

The Love Hypothesis by Ali Hazelwood A scientist agrees to a fake dating arrangement with a professor, leading to unexpected chemistry and the confrontation of past relationship trauma.

The Roommate Risk by Talia Hibbert Two best friends living together must face their buried feelings when an ice storm forces them to share close quarters.

Beach Read by Emily Henry Two writers with opposing styles swap genres for a summer, discovering their personal histories mirror the emotional depth they seek in their work.

The Ex Talk by Rachel Lynn Solomon Radio producers turned co-hosts pretend to be exes for their relationship advice show while navigating real attraction behind the scenes.

Would Like to Meet by Rachel Winters A screenwriter's assistant recreates classic rom-com meet-cutes to prove their worth, encountering genuine connections through staged scenarios.

🌟 Author Sarah Hogle wrote most of Twice Shy during the COVID-19 lockdown, drawing inspiration from her own social anxiety experiences. 🏡 The house featured in the novel was partly inspired by historic homes in the Chattanooga, Tennessee area, where portions of the story take place. 📚 The book explores the concept of "maladaptive daydreaming," a psychological phenomenon where people create elaborate fantasy worlds to escape reality. 💝 The romance novel subverts common tropes by featuring a male lead who is soft-spoken and anxious, rather than the typically confident alpha male character. 🎮 The protagonist's hobby of playing The Sims video game serves as a metaphor for her desire to control her environment and was based on the author's own gaming experiences.