📖 Overview
Refusal to Eat examines hunger strikes in prisons across the 20th century, focusing on protests from London to South Africa to Guantanamo Bay. Through case studies and archival research, the book traces how prisoners used their bodies as instruments of resistance against state power.
The narrative follows political dissidents, suffragettes, civil rights activists and others who employed self-starvation as a tactic. Shah documents the medical, legal and ethical debates that emerged as authorities grappled with hunger strikes, including the controversial practice of force-feeding.
This historical account situates prison hunger strikes within broader movements for human rights and political change. The book analyzes media coverage, public reactions, and lasting policy impacts of these protests across different political contexts.
The work reveals how the seemingly personal act of refusing food became a powerful political weapon, raising fundamental questions about bodily autonomy, state control, and the limits of protest. Through these hunger strikes, Shah illuminates the complex relationship between individual resistance and institutional power.
👀 Reviews
There are not enough internet reviews to create a summary of this book. Instead, here is a summary of reviews of Nayan Shah's overall work:
Readers value Shah's thorough research and clear presentation of complex historical intersections between race, health policy, and social control. Academic reviewers highlight his use of extensive archival materials to document discriminatory public health practices in "Contagious Divides."
What readers liked:
- Detailed primary source evidence
- Clear connections between historical events and current issues
- Accessible writing style for academic texts
- Strong theoretical framework balanced with concrete examples
What readers disliked:
- Dense academic language in some sections
- Limited discussion of resistance movements
- High textbook pricing
- Some repetition of key points
Ratings:
Goodreads:
"Contagious Divides" - 4.1/5 (82 ratings)
"Stranger Intimacy" - 4.3/5 (31 ratings)
From an academic review: "Shah skillfully demonstrates how public health became a weapon of racial segregation" - Journal of American History
Graduate students frequently cite Shah's works as helpful resources for understanding the intersection of public health and racial discrimination in American history.
📚 Similar books
Force-Feeding: Prison Hunger Strikes and Medical Ethics by Elizabeth A. Williams
A medical and ethical history of force-feeding political prisoners, focusing on Britain and the United States from 1909 to 1974.
The IRA in Prison: 1916-1921 by William Murphy The chronicle of Irish Republicans who used hunger strikes as resistance during the Irish War of Independence.
Prison Hunger Strikes in Palestine by Ashjan Ajour An examination of Palestinian prisoners' hunger strikes from 1968 to 2016 as a form of political resistance against Israeli detention.
The Art of Starving by Sharman Apt Russell The cultural and political history of fasting as protest across religions, social movements, and prison systems.
Gandhi's Prisoner? by Faisal Devji An analysis of hunger strikes in South Asian independence movements and their transformation into a modern political weapon.
The IRA in Prison: 1916-1921 by William Murphy The chronicle of Irish Republicans who used hunger strikes as resistance during the Irish War of Independence.
Prison Hunger Strikes in Palestine by Ashjan Ajour An examination of Palestinian prisoners' hunger strikes from 1968 to 2016 as a form of political resistance against Israeli detention.
The Art of Starving by Sharman Apt Russell The cultural and political history of fasting as protest across religions, social movements, and prison systems.
Gandhi's Prisoner? by Faisal Devji An analysis of hunger strikes in South Asian independence movements and their transformation into a modern political weapon.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔶 Author Nayan Shah uncovered that hunger strikes were used strategically by prisoners from vastly different backgrounds - from suffragettes to anarchists to anti-colonial activists - showing how this protest method crossed cultural and ideological lines.
🔶 The book reveals how force-feeding became a widespread practice in prisons during the early 20th century, often involving brutal methods such as nasal tubes and restraint chairs.
🔶 Prison hunger strikes gained significant media attention during the Irish Republican movement of 1917-1923, with the death of hunger striker Terence MacSwiney making international headlines and inspiring similar protests globally.
🔶 Women prisoners were among the earliest and most influential hunger strikers, with suffragettes in Britain and the United States using the tactic to draw attention to their cause and challenge assumptions about gender and political resistance.
🔶 The impact of hunger strikes extended beyond prison walls, influencing medical ethics debates and leading to changes in how doctors approached the conflict between preserving life and respecting patient autonomy.