A Rhetoric of Motives

A Rhetoric of Motives examines human relations through the lens of rhetoric and language. Burke expands the traditional scope of rhetoric beyond persuasion to encompass all forms of human symbolic interaction and identification. Burke analyzes examples from literature, politics, philosophy, and social movements to demonstrate how rhetoric functions in society. The work builds on his earlier theories about dramatism and symbolic action while introducing new frameworks for understanding human motivation and communication. This seminal text develops key concepts like identification, hierarchy, and order that have influenced fields from literary criticism to political science. Through systematic examination of texts and social phenomena, Burke reveals the rhetorical dynamics underlying human cooperation and conflict. The book stands as a foundational work in rhetorical theory that connects language use to broader questions of human nature and social organization. Its insights into how people use symbols to create meaning and foster connection continue to resonate across academic disciplines.

Readers describe this as a dense, theoretical text that requires multiple readings to grasp Burke's concepts. On Goodreads, many note its influence on their understanding of rhetoric and human motivation. Readers appreciate: - Deep analysis of how language shapes social behavior - Burke's examination of identification in human relations - Connections between rhetoric and broader social/political movements Common criticisms: - Complex, abstract writing style - Meandering structure that's hard to follow - Dated references and examples - Need for extensive philosophy/rhetoric background From reviews: "Burke's prose is difficult but rewarding once you work through it" - Goodreads reviewer "The ideas are brilliant but buried under layers of academic jargon" - Amazon review Ratings: Goodreads: 4.1/5 (165 ratings) Amazon: 4.3/5 (22 ratings) Most successful with graduate students and rhetoric scholars rather than general readers seeking an introduction to the topic.

Language as Symbolic Action by Kenneth Burke This work expands on the relationship between language and human motivation through the lens of dramatism and linguistic action.

The Philosophy of Literary Form by Kenneth Burke The text examines how literary forms shape human understanding and social interaction through symbolic systems.

Truth and Method by Hans-Georg Gadamer This philosophical work explores how language and rhetoric function in human understanding and interpretation of meaning.

The New Rhetoric: A Treatise on Argumentation by Chaim Perelman and Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca The book presents a comprehensive theory of argumentation and its role in human reasoning and social discourse.

Permanence and Change by Kenneth Burke The text investigates how humans use language to create and maintain social order while adapting to cultural transformations.

🔰 Kenneth Burke wrote A Rhetoric of Motives (1950) while teaching at Bennington College, but was simultaneously working as a book reviewer, music critic, and short story writer to support his family. 🔰 The book introduces the concept of "identification" as central to rhetoric, shifting focus away from traditional notions of persuasion and suggesting that rhetoric works by establishing common ground between speaker and audience. 🔰 Burke's work influenced fields far beyond rhetoric, including literary criticism, sociology, and psychology. The book is considered part of the "New Rhetoric" movement that revolutionized 20th-century communication theory. 🔰 The phrase "rhetoric of motives" itself suggests that human motivation is inherently rhetorical - that we act not just from pure reason or emotion, but through symbolic systems that shape our understanding of why we do what we do. 🔰 The book is part of Burke's larger "motivorum" trilogy, alongside A Grammar of Motives and an unfinished third volume on symbolic action. Together, these works attempt to create a comprehensive theory of human symbolic behavior.