📖 Overview
Tola Carver faces isolation at her high school after photos of her and a male teacher spread through social media, leading to rampant rumors. Despite the teacher's departure from the school, Tola must navigate her senior year while dealing with bullying, judgment, and the dissolution of friendships.
Her close relationships with her mother and younger sister provide support, but tensions at home increase as the scandal affects the family's reputation in their small town. Tola finds unexpected allies and discovers her own resilience as she refuses to accept the role of victim or outcast.
The narrative examines how social media can amplify cruelty and distort truth, while exploring themes of reputation, loyalty, and the power of human connection. Ruby's story challenges assumptions about guilt and innocence in an era where digital images can tell compelling but incomplete stories.
👀 Reviews
Readers report this book handles difficult topics like bullying and sexual harassment with sensitivity and age-appropriate presentation. The story resonates with middle school students who face similar social pressures.
Readers appreciated:
- Authentic middle school social dynamics
- Strong character development of the protagonist
- Clear messaging about speaking up against harassment
- Relatable family relationships
Common criticisms:
- Plot moves slowly in the middle sections
- Some side characters lack depth
- Several reviews note the resolution feels rushed
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.8/5 (1,200+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.2/5 (80+ reviews)
One parent reviewer stated: "Helped my daughter understand she's not alone in dealing with school drama." Another noted: "The mother-daughter relationship rang especially true."
A critical review mentioned: "Takes too long to get to the main conflict. Could have been 50 pages shorter."
📚 Similar books
Mean Girls by Micol Ostow
This YA novel follows a new student who becomes entangled in high school social warfare and must navigate treachery, rumors, and revenge.
This Is Not A Ghost Story by Andrea Portes A teenage girl takes a job house-sitting in an isolated mansion and uncovers dark secrets that blur the line between reality and paranoia.
The Treatment by Suzanne Young Students at a prestigious boarding school face manipulation and psychological experiments while questioning their own memories and identities.
Genuine Fraud by E. Lockhart The story moves backward in time to reveal how a young woman transformed from a privileged teenager to someone living under an assumed identity.
The Female of the Species by Mindy McGinnis Three high school seniors become linked through violence, secrets, and justice in a small town marked by a brutal crime.
This Is Not A Ghost Story by Andrea Portes A teenage girl takes a job house-sitting in an isolated mansion and uncovers dark secrets that blur the line between reality and paranoia.
The Treatment by Suzanne Young Students at a prestigious boarding school face manipulation and psychological experiments while questioning their own memories and identities.
Genuine Fraud by E. Lockhart The story moves backward in time to reveal how a young woman transformed from a privileged teenager to someone living under an assumed identity.
The Female of the Species by Mindy McGinnis Three high school seniors become linked through violence, secrets, and justice in a small town marked by a brutal crime.
🤔 Interesting facts
🍎 The character of Tola Riley was inspired by Laura Ruby's own experiences as an art student and her observations of how teenage girls are often unfairly labeled as "troubled" or "bad."
🎨 The book tackles the complex issue of student-teacher relationships while also exploring how social media and digital rumors can spiral out of control in high school settings.
📱 Released in 2009, the novel was ahead of its time in addressing cyberbullying and online harassment before these topics became widely discussed in young adult literature.
🖌️ The protagonist's interest in Vermeer paintings serves as both a plot device and a metaphor for how people perceive truth and reality differently.
👥 Laura Ruby drew from her background as a writing instructor at Columbia College Chicago to create authentic dialogue between teachers and students in the novel.