Where the Jews Aren't: The Sad and Absurd Story of Birobidzhan

Masha Gessen chronicles the Soviet Union's creation of Birobidzhan, a Jewish autonomous region in the far eastern reaches of Russia near the Chinese border. This 1928 project aimed to establish a new homeland for Soviet Jews, complete with Yiddish language rights and cultural autonomy. The book traces the experiences of Yiddish poet David Bergelson, who became an advocate for the Birobidzhan project and relocated there from Berlin. Through Bergelson's story, readers follow the trajectory of this unusual social experiment and its place in Soviet and Jewish history. The narrative examines the realities of building a Jewish territory in an inhospitable corner of Siberia, thousands of miles from the centers of Jewish life. The history spans from the region's establishment through Stalin's era and into the present day. This account of Birobidzhan serves as a lens for exploring larger themes of identity, belonging, and the complex relationship between state power and minority populations. The book reveals how utopian visions can intersect with political machinations, often at great human cost.

Readers describe this as a concise history of Stalin's attempt to create a Soviet Jewish homeland. Many note it reads more like a long essay than a comprehensive book. Readers appreciated: - Clear explanation of a lesser-known historical event - Personal family stories woven into broader history - Accessible writing style for complex political topics Common criticisms: - Too brief at 176 pages - Lacks depth on daily life in Birobidzhan - Jumps between time periods in a confusing way - Limited perspective on non-Jewish residents Ratings across platforms: Goodreads: 3.7/5 (467 ratings) Amazon: 4.1/5 (58 ratings) Several reviewers mentioned wanting more details about the actual settlement process and settlers' experiences. One Amazon reviewer noted: "The title promises more than the book delivers - it's more about Soviet Jewish policy than Birobidzhan itself." Multiple readers recommended it as an introduction to the topic but suggested seeking additional sources for deeper understanding.

Red Plenty by Francis Spufford A blend of history and fiction examining Soviet attempts to create a Jewish homeland through the lens of economic planning and human aspirations.

The Yid by Paul Goldberg The tale of Soviet Jews confronting Stalin's final pogrom combines historical events with elements of Shakespearean theater and Jewish folklore.

City of Dreams: The 400-Year Epic History of Immigrant New York by Tyler Anbinder This chronicle traces Jewish immigration patterns and settlement experiences alongside other ethnic groups in New York City from the 1600s through modern times.

The Jews of Silence by Elie Wiesel A reportage of Soviet Jewish life under Communist rule documents the struggle to maintain cultural identity under state repression.

Stalin's Last Crime: The Plot Against the Jewish Doctors by Jonathan Brent and Vladimir Naumov This investigation uncovers the mechanisms of Stalin's anti-Jewish campaign and the fabricated "Doctors' Plot" of 1952-1953.

🌟 The Jewish Autonomous Oblast (Birobidzhan) remains the world's only officially Jewish territory outside of Israel, despite having a current Jewish population of less than 1% of its total residents. 🌟 Author Masha Gessen spent part of their childhood in the Soviet Union and later became a prominent LGBTQ+ activist and outspoken critic of both Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump. 🌟 Yiddish writer David Bergelson, a central figure in the book, initially promoted Birobidzhan enthusiastically but was later executed in 1952 during Stalin's anti-Jewish purges. 🌟 The Soviet propaganda campaign for Birobidzhan included posters in Yiddish and English, promising Jews a "Soviet Jewish Homeland" complete with collective farms and factories, attracting immigrants from as far as Argentina and the United States. 🌟 In 1936, at its peak, the Jewish population of Birobidzhan reached about 18,000 people, but the region's harsh climate, poor infrastructure, and Stalin's purges led to its eventual failure as a Jewish homeland.