📖 Overview
A Year or So with Edgar chronicles a period in the life of Edgar Loftus, a used car salesman in Massachusetts whose financial troubles lead him into questionable business deals. The story takes place across twelve months in the 1970s as Edgar navigulates both his professional and personal relationships.
The narrative follows Edgar's interactions with a cast of characters including fellow car dealers, loan sharks, and his wife Ruth as he tries to keep his business afloat. His decisions and their consequences create a series of interconnected situations that pull him deeper into the local underworld of Boston.
The novel employs Higgins' trademark dialogue-heavy style, with conversations revealing the intricacies of both legal and illegal business transactions in New England. The authentic regional speech patterns and criminal argot establish the time and place with precision.
Through Edgar's story, Higgins explores themes of economic survival, moral compromise, and the blurred lines between legitimate enterprise and criminal activity in American small business culture.
👀 Reviews
There are not enough internet reviews to create a summary of this book. Instead, here is a summary of reviews of George V. Higgins's overall work:
Readers consistently highlight Higgins' mastery of dialogue, with many noting how his characters' conversations drive the narrative. One Amazon reviewer called "The Friends of Eddie Coyle" "pure dialogue that reads like a court transcript but hits harder."
Readers appreciate:
- Authentic criminal world details
- Natural-sounding Boston dialogue
- Complex moral situations
- Lack of typical crime novel clichés
Common criticisms:
- Dense dialogue can be hard to follow
- Limited action sequences
- Minimal physical descriptions
- Plot development can feel slow
On Goodreads, "The Friends of Eddie Coyle" maintains a 4.0/5 rating from over 8,000 readers. Amazon reviews average 4.2/5 across his works. Multiple readers note the books require concentration, with one stating: "You can't skim this - every conversation matters."
Later novels receive lower ratings (3.5-3.8) with readers citing repetitive themes and overreliance on dialogue. Several mention needing to re-read passages to track who's speaking.
📚 Similar books
The Friends of Eddie Coyle by George V. Higgins
This gritty crime novel captures Boston's criminal underworld through sharp dialogue and street-level dealings, mirroring the authenticity found in A Year or So with Edgar.
Cogan's Trade by George V. Higgins The story follows professional enforcer Jackie Cogan through Boston's criminal underground using the same dialogue-driven narrative style that characterizes Higgins' works.
The Gospel According to Charlie by Robert H. Rimmer This narrative chronicles life in the Boston area through interconnected stories and relationships that paint a picture of New England society.
God Save the Child by Robert B. Parker The Spenser detective series entry presents Boston's social landscape through the lens of a private investigator working among the city's various social classes.
The Given Day by Dennis Lehane This historical crime novel explores Boston's social fabric and criminal elements in the early 20th century through multiple storylines and perspectives.
Cogan's Trade by George V. Higgins The story follows professional enforcer Jackie Cogan through Boston's criminal underground using the same dialogue-driven narrative style that characterizes Higgins' works.
The Gospel According to Charlie by Robert H. Rimmer This narrative chronicles life in the Boston area through interconnected stories and relationships that paint a picture of New England society.
God Save the Child by Robert B. Parker The Spenser detective series entry presents Boston's social landscape through the lens of a private investigator working among the city's various social classes.
The Given Day by Dennis Lehane This historical crime novel explores Boston's social fabric and criminal elements in the early 20th century through multiple storylines and perspectives.
🤔 Interesting facts
🎭 Edgar Driscoll, the title character, is partly inspired by real defense attorney F. Lee Bailey, who gained fame for his involvement in high-profile cases like the O.J. Simpson trial.
📚 George V. Higgins worked as both a federal prosecutor and criminal defense attorney before becoming a novelist, bringing authentic legal expertise to his courtroom scenes.
⚖️ The book's dialogue-heavy style revolutionized crime fiction writing, influencing later authors like Elmore Leonard, who cited Higgins as a major inspiration.
🗣️ Higgins developed his distinctive writing style by transcribing courtroom conversations as a young journalist, leading to his masterful ear for natural dialogue.
📍 The novel is set in Boston's legal community during the 1970s, capturing a pivotal time when the city's traditional power structure was being challenged by social and political changes.