📖 Overview
Philosophical Troubles collects nine essays by influential philosopher Saul Kripke, spanning several decades of his work in metaphysics, epistemology, and philosophy of language. The papers address fundamental questions about reference, truth, belief, and the foundations of logic.
Each essay stands as a self-contained investigation while connecting to broader themes across Kripke's philosophical contributions. Key topics include semantic paradoxes, the nature of belief and assertion, and theories of truth.
The collection includes both previously published papers and new work, representing Kripke's sustained engagement with core philosophical problems. Technical arguments are balanced with clear exposition of the underlying issues at stake.
This volume demonstrates the interconnection between seemingly disparate areas of philosophy, revealing how precise logical analysis can illuminate questions about meaning, knowledge, and reality. The papers showcase Kripke's distinctive approach to philosophical methodology and argumentation.
👀 Reviews
Readers note this collection contains several of Kripke's key papers on reference, belief, and truth. Philosophy students and academics make up most reviewers.
Liked:
- Papers on puzzles about belief and reference offer clear explanations
- The footnotes add valuable context to Kripke's arguments
- Paper on truth stands out for addressing Russell's paradox
- Technical precision while remaining readable
Disliked:
- Several papers repeat content from Kripke's other works
- Some arguments feel incomplete or too brief
- Dense writing requires multiple re-reads
- High price for relatively slim volume
As one Goodreads reviewer notes: "The paper on truth is worth the price alone, but some other entries feel like lecture notes rather than complete arguments."
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.24/5 (17 ratings)
Amazon: 4.5/5 (6 ratings)
PhilPapers: Referenced in 147 citations
Most reviews come from academic philosophy journals rather than general readers.
📚 Similar books
Essays on Reference, Language, and Mind by Tyler Burge
This collection explores the nature of mental content, linguistic meaning, and self-knowledge through interconnected papers that build on Kripke's work in philosophy of language and mind.
Truth and Predication by Donald Davidson The book presents Davidson's final theory on truth, meaning, and predication while addressing fundamental questions about the relationship between language and reality.
From a Logical Point of View by W.V. Quine These nine essays examine reference, meaning, and ontological commitment through Quine's systematic approach to philosophical logic.
The Philosophy of Language by Scott Soames This work traces the development of key concepts in philosophy of language from Frege to Kripke while presenting original arguments about meaning and reference.
Mind and World by John McDowell The text bridges the gap between mind and reality by examining how conceptual thought relates to empirical experience through a series of connected lectures.
Truth and Predication by Donald Davidson The book presents Davidson's final theory on truth, meaning, and predication while addressing fundamental questions about the relationship between language and reality.
From a Logical Point of View by W.V. Quine These nine essays examine reference, meaning, and ontological commitment through Quine's systematic approach to philosophical logic.
The Philosophy of Language by Scott Soames This work traces the development of key concepts in philosophy of language from Frege to Kripke while presenting original arguments about meaning and reference.
Mind and World by John McDowell The text bridges the gap between mind and reality by examining how conceptual thought relates to empirical experience through a series of connected lectures.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔹 Saul Kripke wrote his first groundbreaking paper on modal logic at age 17, while still in high school, and would later expand on these ideas in several essays included in this collection.
🔹 The essays in this volume span over 40 years of Kripke's work, with topics ranging from truth theory to the analysis of belief, showcasing his evolution as a philosopher.
🔹 Kripke famously refused to write down many of his lectures and ideas, preferring to speak extemporaneously, making this collection particularly valuable as a written record of his thought.
🔹 The book contains Kripke's influential paper "A Puzzle About Belief," which challenges fundamental assumptions about how we understand and attribute beliefs to others.
🔹 Despite never completing his undergraduate degree, Kripke became one of the most important philosophers of the 20th century and was awarded the Schock Prize, philosophy's equivalent to the Nobel Prize.