Presidential Greatness: The Image and the Man from George Washington to the Present

Thomas A. Bailey examines the complex relationship between presidential image and reality in this study of American presidents from George Washington through the modern era. The work analyzes how public perception, media coverage, and historical circumstances have shaped the reputations of U.S. presidents both during and after their terms. The book draws from historical documents, contemporary accounts, and scholarly research to trace the evolution of presidential images over time. Bailey contrasts the carefully constructed public personas of presidents with their actual governing styles, decisions, and personal characteristics. Each president receives focused attention exploring the gap between their popular image and documented record. The work demonstrates how factors like war, economic conditions, and changing social values have influenced the way presidents are remembered and evaluated by historians and the public. The narrative raises questions about the nature of presidential greatness and how shifting cultural perspectives affect assessments of leadership. Through this historical lens, the book examines enduring tensions between myth and reality in American political life.

There are not enough internet reviews to create a summary of this book. Instead, here is a summary of reviews of Thomas A. Bailey's overall work: Readers appreciate Bailey's clear writing style and ability to make diplomatic history engaging. Students and teachers cite "The American Pageant" as more readable than typical history textbooks, with memorable phrases and analogies that help explain complex topics. Liked: - Clear organization of complex historical events - Inclusion of primary source documents - Effective use of anecdotes and examples - Balance between depth and accessibility Disliked: - Some dated language and perspectives in older editions - Occasional oversimplification of complex issues - High textbook price point - Some readers note pro-American bias in international relations coverage Ratings: Goodreads: "The American Pageant" - 3.7/5 (500+ ratings) Amazon: 4.2/5 across editions (1000+ reviews) Notable reader comment: "Bailey manages to present diplomatic history without getting bogged down in jargon while still maintaining academic rigor" - Amazon reviewer Students specifically mention the textbook's chapter-end review questions as helpful study tools, though some find the witty writing style distracting from the core content.

Where They Stand: The American Presidents in the Eyes of Voters and Historians by Robert W. Merry This analysis draws from electoral results, surveys, and historical data to examine how presidents have been judged throughout American history.

The Presidents Club: Inside the World's Most Exclusive Fraternity by Nancy Gibbs, Michael Duffy The book reveals the private relationships and interactions between sitting presidents and their predecessors from Truman to Obama.

How Democratic Is the American Constitution? by Robert Dahl This examination of the American presidency explores the evolution of executive power and its impact on democratic governance through multiple administrations.

Presidential Leadership in Political Time: Reprise and Reappraisal by Stephen Skowronek The book presents a framework for understanding presidential leadership through patterns of authority and opposition across different historical periods.

Dead Presidents: An American Adventure into the Strange Deaths and Surprising Afterlives of Our Nation's Leaders by Brady Carlson This historical account traces the legacy of American presidents through the monuments, ceremonies, and cultural practices that have preserved their memory.

🔹 Thomas A. Bailey was a diplomatic historian at Stanford University for nearly 40 years and authored the widely-used American history textbook "The American Pageant," which is still in use today in updated editions. 🔹 The book analyzes how public perception of presidents has changed over time, noting that some presidents (like U.S. Grant) were initially rated poorly by historians but have been reassessed more favorably in recent decades. 🔹 Bailey's work was one of the first comprehensive studies to examine the gap between presidents' contemporary reputations and their historical legacies, highlighting how time and perspective can dramatically shift presidential rankings. 🔹 The book's methodology includes analysis of contemporary newspaper accounts, personal letters, and diaries to show how presidents were viewed during their own time periods, rather than relying solely on historical hindsight. 🔹 When discussing George Washington's presidency, Bailey reveals that Washington deliberately crafted his public image, carefully choosing to be addressed as "Mr. President" rather than grander titles that were suggested, like "His High Mightiness" or "His Elected Majesty."