Illusions of Victory: The Anbar Awakening and the Rise of the Islamic State

Carter Malkasian examines the Anbar Awakening movement in Iraq between 2006-2008, when Sunni tribes allied with U.S. forces against Al Qaeda. The book focuses on this critical period through extensive research and firsthand accounts from both American and Iraqi perspectives. The narrative traces the complex dynamics between tribal leaders, U.S. military commanders, and insurgent groups in Anbar province. Military strategy, tribal politics, and shifting allegiances form the core of this account of counterinsurgency operations in western Iraq. The analysis draws on hundreds of interviews, internal military documents, and Arabic language sources to reconstruct events. Malkasian's experience as a civilian advisor in Iraq adds depth to his investigation of this pivotal chapter in the Iraq War. The book challenges conventional wisdom about the effectiveness of counterinsurgency doctrine and raises important questions about the long-term sustainability of military solutions to political problems.

Readers value the book's detailed analysis of how the Anbar Awakening's success was temporary and ultimately failed to prevent ISIS's rise. Military personnel and academics note the thorough research and documentation. Positives from reviews: - Provides counterpoints to the prevailing narrative about the Awakening's effectiveness - Draws on firsthand interviews and primary sources - Explains complex tribal dynamics clearly Criticisms from reviews: - Some sections become repetitive - Could have included more Iraqi perspectives - A few readers found the writing style dry Ratings: Goodreads: 4.1/5 (19 ratings) Amazon: 4.5/5 (12 ratings) One reviewer on Amazon noted: "Malkasian effectively dismantles the myth that the Awakening was a lasting victory." A Goodreads reviewer highlighted that "the book fills an important gap in understanding why initial successes against insurgents didn't translate to long-term stability."

The Muslims are Coming by Arun Kundnani A historical analysis of counterterrorism policies and Islamic radicalization in the US and UK from 2001-2016.

The Fighters by C. J. Chivers The Iraq and Afghanistan wars through the experiences of six American combatants from 2001-2016.

The ISIS Apocalypse by William McCants An examination of ISIS's rise through its religious ideology and military strategy in Iraq and Syria.

Iraq After America by Joel Rayburn A military historian's account of Iraq's descent into sectarian conflict following the US military withdrawal.

The Endgame by Michael R. Gordon A chronicle of the Iraq War from the 2003 invasion through the emergence of ISIS in 2014.

🔹 The Anbar Awakening (2006-2008) was initially a tribal rebellion against Al-Qaeda in Iraq, led by Sheikh Abdul Sattar Abu Risha, who was later assassinated by his enemies. 🔹 Author Carter Malkasian spent nearly two years in Iraq's Al Anbar province working directly with American Marines and Iraqi leaders during this critical period. 🔹 Despite being considered a success story in counterinsurgency, many of the same areas that participated in the Awakening later became strongholds for ISIS by 2014. 🔹 The book challenges the conventional wisdom that the Awakening was primarily a result of American military strategy, arguing instead that local Iraqi dynamics played a more decisive role. 🔹 The author served as the Special Assistant for Strategy to the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Joseph Dunford, making him uniquely qualified to analyze both military and political aspects of the conflict.