Explaining Value and Other Essays in Moral Philosophy

Explaining Value and Other Essays in Moral Philosophy presents Gilbert Harman's key writings on moral relativism, moral explanations, and the nature of moral facts. The collection brings together essays written over several decades that examine fundamental questions in ethics and metaethics. Harman develops arguments for moral relativism while exploring how moral facts might relate to scientific explanations and observations. He investigates whether moral properties are reducible to natural properties and analyzes the role of moral psychology in understanding ethical behavior. The essays address topics including moral observation, the relationship between values and motivation, and challenges to moral realism. Harman engages with other philosophers' views while building his case for a naturalistic approach to ethics. The work contributes to ongoing debates about moral truth and knowledge by examining the foundations of ethical reasoning and the connection between moral judgments and empirical facts. The essays collectively point toward a coherent framework for understanding morality within a scientific worldview.

This academic philosophy text has limited reader reviews online, making it difficult to gauge broad reception. Readers appreciated Harman's clear writing style and systematic approach to explaining moral relativism and value theory. Philosophy students noted its usefulness in understanding key concepts about moral judgment and practical reasoning. Critics found some chapters overly technical and pointed out that the essay collection feels disjointed rather than cohesive. A few readers mentioned the book works better as a reference than a cover-to-cover read. Available Ratings: Goodreads: 3.67/5 (3 ratings, 0 written reviews) Amazon: No reviews Google Books: No reviews Note: This book is primarily used in academic settings and graduate-level philosophy courses, which likely explains the limited number of public reviews. Most discussion appears in academic journals rather than consumer review platforms.

Ethics: Inventing Right and Wrong by J. L. Mackie This work examines moral skepticism and argues against the objective existence of moral facts through philosophical analysis.

Value, Reality, and Desire by Graham Oddie The text explores the relationship between values and reality while addressing fundamental questions in moral metaphysics.

The View From Nowhere by Thomas Nagel This philosophical investigation connects moral relativism, objectivity, and perspective in ethical reasoning.

Moral Relativism and Moral Objectivity by Gilbert Harman, Judith Jarvis Thomson The book presents contrasting perspectives on moral truth through a structured debate between two philosophers.

Essays on Moral Realism by Geoffrey Sayre-McCord This collection examines the foundations of moral realism through contributions from multiple philosophers who address metaethical questions.

🔹 Gilbert Harman, while writing this collection of essays, was the Stuart Professor of Philosophy at Princeton University, where he taught for over 45 years and helped shape modern moral philosophy. 🔹 The book tackles the controversial topic of moral relativism, with Harman arguing that morality is relative to agreements among people rather than absolute or universal truths. 🔹 Published in 2000, this work builds upon Harman's influential 1977 book "The Nature of Morality," expanding his views on moral relativism and responding to two decades of criticism. 🔹 The essays explore the connection between moral philosophy and cognitive science, particularly how findings about the human brain and psychology should influence our understanding of ethics. 🔹 Harman challenges the traditional view that moral facts can be observed, arguing instead that moral observations are actually theoretical inferences, similar to how scientists make inferences about unobservable particles.