Book
The Things We Do With Words: Ilongot Speech Acts and Speech Act Theory in Philosophy
📖 Overview
Rosaldo's ethnographic study examines speech acts and language use among the Ilongot people of northern Luzon in the Philippines. Her research challenges Western philosophical assumptions about speech act theory through detailed analysis of Ilongot linguistic practices.
The book presents extensive fieldwork data collected during Rosaldo's time living among the Ilongot, documenting their everyday conversations, ritual speech, and social interactions. Her work demonstrates how cultural context shapes the meaning and function of utterances in ways not accounted for by traditional speech act theory.
Through careful examination of Ilongot language practices, Rosaldo reveals the limitations of universalist approaches to linguistic analysis and speech acts. The study bridges anthropological and philosophical approaches to understanding how people use words to accomplish social actions.
The work stands as a significant contribution to both linguistic anthropology and philosophy of language, questioning fundamental assumptions about the relationship between speech, meaning, and social action across cultures.
👀 Reviews
There are not enough internet reviews to create a summary of this book. Instead, here is a summary of reviews of Michelle Zimbalist Rosaldo's overall work:
Michelle Zimbalist Rosaldo's works receive respect in academic circles for their empirical research and theoretical frameworks examining gender relations.
Readers appreciate:
- Detailed ethnographic observations of Ilongot culture
- Clear analysis connecting gender roles to broader social structures
- Accessible writing style for complex anthropological concepts
- Evidence-based challenges to biological determinism arguments
- Integration of feminist theory with fieldwork data
Common criticisms:
- Some dated theoretical concepts from 1970s feminist scholarship
- Limited sample size in ethnographic studies
- Writing can be dense with academic terminology
- Some readers find the public/private sphere framework oversimplified
Ratings/Reviews:
- "Woman, Culture & Society" maintains 4.1/5 on Goodreads (127 ratings)
- Her works are frequently cited in anthropology course syllabi and academic papers
- Journal reviews highlight innovative methodology but note limitations of data scope
- Graduate students praise the theoretical frameworks while undergraduate readers report difficulty with technical language
Most reviews come from academic settings rather than general readers due to the scholarly nature of her work.
📚 Similar books
Speech Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy of Language by John R. Searle
This foundational text explores how language performs actions through detailed analysis of linguistic structures and their social functions.
How to Do Things with Words by J.L. Austin The book presents the theory of performative utterances and establishes core concepts about speech acts that influenced anthropological studies of language.
Language and Social Relations by Asif Agha This work examines how speech patterns and linguistic practices connect to social relationships and cultural identities across different societies.
Words of Light: Theses on the Photography of History by Eduardo Cadava The text analyzes language as a form of social action through the lens of historical and philosophical discourse.
The Ethnography of Communication by Dell Hymes This seminal work presents methods for studying how language functions within cultural contexts and shapes social interactions.
How to Do Things with Words by J.L. Austin The book presents the theory of performative utterances and establishes core concepts about speech acts that influenced anthropological studies of language.
Language and Social Relations by Asif Agha This work examines how speech patterns and linguistic practices connect to social relationships and cultural identities across different societies.
Words of Light: Theses on the Photography of History by Eduardo Cadava The text analyzes language as a form of social action through the lens of historical and philosophical discourse.
The Ethnography of Communication by Dell Hymes This seminal work presents methods for studying how language functions within cultural contexts and shapes social interactions.
🤔 Interesting facts
🗣️ Michelle Rosaldo conducted extensive fieldwork living among the Ilongot people of northern Luzon, Philippines, with her husband Renato Rosaldo during the 1970s
📚 The book challenges Western philosophical assumptions about speech acts by examining how the Ilongot's use of language differs fundamentally from English-speaking cultures
🌿 The Ilongot people, who are the focus of this study, were known as headhunters until the practice ended in the 1970s, and their language reflects complex social relationships and emotional concepts
👥 Rosaldo's work demonstrates how the Ilongot language lacks direct equivalents for English performative verbs like "promise" or "declare," yet achieves similar social functions through different linguistic means
🎓 The book became highly influential in both anthropology and linguistics, helping establish the importance of studying speech acts across cultures rather than assuming universal patterns based on Western languages