The Perils of Belonging: Autochthony, Citizenship, and Exclusion in Africa and Europe

The Perils of Belonging examines the rise of autochthony - the claim to be an original inhabitant of a territory - in both Africa and Europe. Through field research in Cameroon and comparative analysis across regions, Peter Geschiere investigates how ideas of belonging and "native" rights have gained prominence in politics and daily life. His ethnographic work traces the transformation of autochthony from a relatively flexible concept in many African societies to an exclusionary political tool. The book draws connections between seemingly disparate cases: land disputes in Cameroon, citizenship debates in Côte d'Ivoire, and anti-immigration movements in the Netherlands and Flanders. The research spans multiple decades and incorporates historical records, interviews, and participant observation across continents. Geschiere documents how claims of being "sons of the soil" manifest in local conflicts while also shaping national politics and global migration debates. This comparative study reveals how autochthony - despite its promise of ancient roots and stability - produces shifting and volatile dynamics of inclusion and exclusion. The work contributes to broader discussions about citizenship, nationalism, and belonging in an interconnected world.

Readers note this academic work breaks new ground in examining autochthony movements and citizenship claims across Africa and Europe. Several reviewers highlight the comprehensive case studies from Cameroon and Ivory Coast paired with analysis of parallel trends in Western Europe. Readers appreciated: - Clear links between seemingly disparate global contexts - Detailed fieldwork and primary sources - Focus on both historical roots and contemporary implications Common criticisms: - Dense academic language makes it less accessible to general readers - Some sections are repetitive - Limited coverage of certain regions mentioned in the title Ratings: Goodreads: 3.9/5 (14 ratings) Amazon: No ratings available Google Books: No ratings available Academic journal reviews praise the book's contribution to understanding citizenship and belonging in a globalized world. One reviewer on Academia.edu notes it "provides an essential theoretical framework for analyzing contemporary conflicts over belonging and exclusion."

Citizen and Subject by Mahmood Mamdani This examination of colonial and post-colonial African politics explores how European rule created systems of ethnic citizenship that continue to shape belonging and exclusion in modern African states.

The Politics of Belonging by Nira Yuval-Davis The book provides a framework for understanding how identity, citizenship, and nationalism intersect to create boundaries between those who belong and those who do not in contemporary societies.

Native Strangers by Peter Geschiere and Francis Nyamnjoh Through case studies from Cameroon and South Africa, this work examines how questions of belonging and citizenship manifest in local contexts during periods of rapid social change.

Nations and Nationalism by Ernest Gellner This theoretical exploration of nationalism investigates how modern states create and maintain concepts of national belonging through cultural and political mechanisms.

Identity and Violence by Amartya Sen The book analyzes how singular identities based on nationality, ethnicity, or religion lead to exclusion and conflict in modern societies.

🌍 The concept of "autochthony" - meaning "born from the soil" - has been used both to unite and divide communities across Africa and Europe, despite their vastly different cultural contexts. 📚 Peter Geschiere spent over three decades conducting fieldwork in Cameroon, giving him unique insights into how claims of "belonging" can transform from inclusive to exclusionary principles. 🗝️ The book reveals how the seemingly innocent idea of "belonging to the soil" became a powerful political tool in places as diverse as Côte d'Ivoire and the Netherlands. 🏛️ During the 1990s, when many African countries transitioned to multiparty democracy, debates about who truly "belongs" intensified dramatically, often leading to violent conflicts. 🌿 The research shows how global trends like immigration and democratization have paradoxically strengthened local claims to authenticity and indigenous rights, rather than diminishing them.