The Responsibilities of the Critic

The Responsibilities of the Critic collects F.O. Matthiessen's essays and lectures on literary criticism from the 1940s and early 1950s. The book was published posthumously in 1952, gathering his key writings on the role and duties of the literary critic in modern society. Matthiessen examines the relationship between criticism, literature, and democracy through analysis of American writers like Emerson, Whitman, and Henry James. He connects literary criticism to broader cultural and political contexts while maintaining focus on close reading of texts. These essays chart Matthiessen's development of what he terms "democratic criticism" - an approach that balances scholarly rigor with accessibility and social conscience. The collection preserves his final thoughts on criticism before his death in 1950. The work presents an argument for literary criticism as a vital force in maintaining democratic culture and fostering critical thinking. Through these pieces, Matthiessen establishes a framework for understanding criticism as both an art and a civic responsibility.

This book appears to have limited reader reviews online, with no entries on Goodreads or Amazon, likely due to its academic nature and publication date (1952). The text compiles Matthiessen's lectures and essays about literary criticism. Readers highlighted: - Clear breakdown of a critic's obligations to authors and audiences - Detailed analysis of American literature's social responsibilities - Practical insights into reviewing methodology Points of criticism: - Dense academic language that can be difficult to follow - Some concepts feel dated by modern critical standards - Focus primarily on male authors of the time period The book is primarily referenced in academic papers and scholarly works rather than reviewed by general readers. No aggregate ratings could be found on major book review sites or academic databases. Most mentions appear in citations and bibliographies rather than direct reviews. Academic journals cite it mainly for its influence on mid-20th century American literary criticism methods.

The Function of Criticism by T.S. Eliot This landmark text examines the role of critics in shaping cultural discourse and maintaining literary standards across generations.

The Arts of Reading by Fred Newton Scott and Joseph Villiers Denney This work presents methods for critical engagement with texts and outlines principles for evaluating literary merit.

The Armed Vision by Stanley Edgar Hyman The book analyzes different schools of literary criticism and their methodologies through case studies of major critics.

Theory of Literature by René Wellek, Austin Warren This systematic study explores the foundations of literary criticism and its relationship to other disciplines in the humanities.

The Mirror and the Lamp by M. H. Abrams The text traces the evolution of critical theory from classical to modern times through the examination of fundamental metaphors in criticism.

🔖 F.O. Matthiessen taught at Harvard University for 22 years and helped establish American Studies as a legitimate academic discipline through his groundbreaking scholarship. 📚 The book was published posthumously in 1952, following Matthiessen's tragic death by suicide in 1950, and consists of lectures he delivered at various universities. 💭 Matthiessen coined the term "American Renaissance" to describe the extraordinary flowering of American literature in the 1850s, which became a fundamental concept in American literary studies. 📖 The book argues that literary criticism should connect literature to broader social and cultural contexts, reflecting Matthiessen's belief that criticism had a vital democratic function. 🎓 Despite being one of America's most influential literary critics, Matthiessen faced persecution during the McCarthy era for his political views and his sexuality, which likely contributed to his death.