Book
No Race-Baiting, Red-Baiting, or Queer-Baiting: The Marine Cooks and Stewards Union from the Depression to the Cold War
by Allan Bérubé
📖 Overview
No Race-Baiting, Red-Baiting, or Queer-Baiting chronicles the history of the Marine Cooks and Stewards Union (MCSU) from the 1930s through the early Cold War period. The book examines this radical maritime labor union that operated primarily on the West Coast of the United States during a transformative era in American labor history.
The narrative focuses on the MCSU's groundbreaking approach to racial integration, sexuality, and leftist politics within its ranks. Through extensive research and archival materials, Bérubé reconstructs the day-to-day operations and key moments in the union's development as it fought for workers' rights aboard passenger ships and freighters.
The union's struggles play out against the broader canvas of Depression-era labor movements, World War II, and the onset of McCarthyism. Bérubé documents the personal stories of union members alongside the larger institutional challenges faced by the MCSU during these pivotal decades.
This work presents an alternative vision of American unionism that challenged conventional boundaries of race, sexuality, and political ideology. The MCSU's story offers insights into the possibilities and limitations of radical labor organizing in mid-twentieth century America.
👀 Reviews
There are not enough internet reviews to create a summary of this book. Instead, here is a summary of reviews of Allan Bérubé's overall work:
Readers praise Bérubé's thorough research and engaging writing style in "Coming Out Under Fire," noting his ability to blend personal stories with historical analysis. Many reviews highlight how the book reveals previously undocumented aspects of WWII history through firsthand accounts and letters.
What readers liked:
- Clear, accessible writing that avoids academic jargon
- Extensive use of primary sources and oral histories
- Balance of individual stories with broader historical context
What readers disliked:
- Some found the organizational structure jumps between topics
- A few noted the book focuses more on gay men than lesbian experiences
- Limited coverage of racial minorities' experiences
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.2/5 (500+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.5/5 (50+ reviews)
Notable reader comment: "Bérubé lets the voices of these veterans speak for themselves while providing crucial historical framework" - Goodreads reviewer
The book continues to receive consistent positive reviews from both academic and general readers for its contribution to LGBTQ military history.
📚 Similar books
Sailors and Stewards: Jim Crow at Sea by Brian Greenberg
This book examines racial integration and labor activism among maritime workers from 1930-1960.
Red Seas: Ferdinand Smith and Radical Black Sailors by Gerald Horne The story tracks Communist organizer Ferdinand Smith's work uniting Black and white sailors in the National Maritime Union.
Queer Clout: Chicago and the Rise of Gay Politics by Timothy Stewart-Winter Chronicles labor unions' role in early LGBTQ workplace organizing and civil rights efforts in mid-century Chicago.
Making History: The American Left and the American Mind by Richard Flacks Documents how radical labor unions shaped social movements and political consciousness from the 1930s through the McCarthy era.
Brothers: Black and Poor - A True Story of Courage and Survival by William Kornblum Follows the lives of Black maritime workers who faced discrimination while building interracial unions on America's waterfronts.
Red Seas: Ferdinand Smith and Radical Black Sailors by Gerald Horne The story tracks Communist organizer Ferdinand Smith's work uniting Black and white sailors in the National Maritime Union.
Queer Clout: Chicago and the Rise of Gay Politics by Timothy Stewart-Winter Chronicles labor unions' role in early LGBTQ workplace organizing and civil rights efforts in mid-century Chicago.
Making History: The American Left and the American Mind by Richard Flacks Documents how radical labor unions shaped social movements and political consciousness from the 1930s through the McCarthy era.
Brothers: Black and Poor - A True Story of Courage and Survival by William Kornblum Follows the lives of Black maritime workers who faced discrimination while building interracial unions on America's waterfronts.
🤔 Interesting facts
📚 The Marine Cooks and Stewards Union (MCSU) was one of the most racially integrated unions in the United States during the 1930s and 1940s, with African Americans making up nearly half of its leadership positions.
🌊 The union represented workers who served as cooks, waiters, bartenders, and stewards aboard passenger ships along the Pacific Coast, creating a unique multicultural workplace environment at sea.
✍️ Author Allan Bérubé was a pioneering LGBTQ historian who passed away in 2007 before completing this book; the manuscript was edited and published posthumously by his colleagues in 2011.
⚓ The MCSU was known for its slogan "No Race-Baiting, Red-Baiting, or Queer-Baiting," making it one of the earliest American labor organizations to explicitly oppose discrimination based on sexuality.
🏛️ The union was eventually destroyed during the McCarthy era, largely due to its progressive stance on racial equality and its left-wing political affiliations, which made it a target of anti-communist investigations.