📖 Overview
Sports journalist Adele Harris returns to her Texas hometown after years of experiencing nothing but terrible dates. When she encounters former college flame Zach Zemaitis, now a successful football coach and widower, their past relationship resurfaces.
The story centers on their rekindled connection in a small-town setting, while both characters navigate their careers and family obligations. Adele must overcome her skepticism about romance, shaped by her history of dating disasters.
As a contemporary romance, the book balances humor with emotional depth through its exploration of second chances and overcoming past hurts. The narrative examines how timing and maturity can transform a relationship that didn't work in youth.
The novel touches on themes of fate versus choice in love, and questions whether people can truly change over time. Through its central romance, it considers how past experiences shape our willingness to risk our hearts again.
👀 Reviews
Readers describe this as a light romantic comedy with witty dialogue and chemistry between the leads. The book maintains a quick pace and includes both humor and emotional depth according to reviews.
Readers appreciated:
- The realistic portrayal of dating struggles
- Snappy banter between characters
- The sports journalism backdrop
- References to previous books in the series while working as a standalone
Common criticisms:
- Predictable plot points
- Some found the supernatural element unnecessary
- Several readers noted the romance develops too quickly
- Character development feels rushed in later chapters
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.95/5 (11,800+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.4/5 (180+ reviews)
"The humor kept me engaged even when the plot felt familiar" - Goodreads reviewer
"Loved the dialogue but wished for more depth in the relationship development" - Amazon review
"Fun escape read but not as memorable as her other books" - Barnes & Noble review
📚 Similar books
Call Me Irresistible by Susan Elizabeth Phillips
A romance about a woman who stops a wedding and falls for the jilted groom combines small-town dynamics with second chances.
The Cheat Sheet by Sarah Adams A friends-to-lovers romance between a professional athlete and his best friend features misunderstandings and fake dating scenarios.
Until There Was You by Kristan Higgins A reunion romance between former high school opposites brings together a bad boy turned responsible businessman and a former good girl.
Practice Makes Perfect by Julie James Two competing lawyers who dislike each other must work together while fighting their growing attraction.
Bet Me by Jennifer Crusie A skeptical actuary and a charming man enter a dating bet that leads to unexpected complications and romance.
The Cheat Sheet by Sarah Adams A friends-to-lovers romance between a professional athlete and his best friend features misunderstandings and fake dating scenarios.
Until There Was You by Kristan Higgins A reunion romance between former high school opposites brings together a bad boy turned responsible businessman and a former good girl.
Practice Makes Perfect by Julie James Two competing lawyers who dislike each other must work together while fighting their growing attraction.
Bet Me by Jennifer Crusie A skeptical actuary and a charming man enter a dating bet that leads to unexpected complications and romance.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 Rachel Gibson worked as an insurance agent before becoming a bestselling romance author, and she wrote her first book while juggling a full-time job and raising two children.
📚 The book is set in Truly, Idaho - a fictional small town that appears in several of Gibson's novels, creating an interconnected universe for her readers.
💕 The protagonist, Adele Harris, is a professor of medieval literature, which the author uses to weave clever parallels between classic romantic tales and modern dating experiences.
🏆 "Not Another Bad Date" was published in 2008 and helped establish Gibson as one of the pioneers of contemporary sports romance, though this particular book focuses more on second-chance romance.
✍️ The novel features a unique supernatural element where the heroine's bad dates are caused by a curse from her deceased sister - a plot device that sets it apart from typical contemporary romance novels.