📖 Overview
American Musical Comedy: From Adonis to Dreamgirls chronicles the evolution of American musical theater from 1884 to 1981. This historical overview traces nearly 100 years of theatrical development through both successful and lesser-known productions.
The book examines major shifts in musical comedy style, from early vaudeville influences through the emergence of integrated storylines. Bordman documents the contributions of key composers, lyricists, directors, and performers who shaped the genre during each era.
The text incorporates primary source materials including reviews, production notes, and firsthand accounts from theater professionals. Statistical data and financial records help illustrate Broadway's changing landscape across decades.
Bordman's analysis reveals how musical comedy both reflected and influenced American cultural values and social attitudes throughout the 20th century. The genre's progression mirrors broader changes in entertainment, technology, and artistic expression during this transformative period.
👀 Reviews
There are not enough internet reviews to create a summary of this book. Instead, here is a summary of reviews of Gerald Bordman's overall work:
Readers value Bordman's books primarily as detailed reference sources for theater research and historical documentation. Reviews highlight the encyclopedic scope and chronological organization of his works, particularly The American Musical Theatre: A Chronicle.
What readers liked:
- Comprehensive coverage of both famous and obscure productions
- Clear chronological structure
- Detailed production information and cast lists
- Usefulness for academic research
What readers disliked:
- Dense, dry writing style
- Limited analysis or interpretation
- Focus on facts over storytelling
- Some factual errors in early editions
Ratings average 4.2/5 on Goodreads and 4.4/5 on Amazon across his titles. Multiple reader reviews describe the books as "exhaustive" and "thorough." One Amazon reviewer notes they are "better as reference works than reading cover-to-cover." Several academic reviewers praise the bibliographic detail while critiquing the lack of cultural context. Library Journal called his writing "authoritative but sometimes tedious."
📚 Similar books
Broadway: The American Musical by Michael Kantor
A chronicle of Broadway musicals from the 1800s through modern times traces the development of musical theater through archival photographs, behind-the-scenes stories, and cultural context.
Our Musicals, Ourselves by John Bush Jones The text examines American musicals as reflections of U.S. social history, connecting shows to specific decades and historical events from the 1920s through 2001.
Changed for Good: A Feminist History of the Broadway Musical by Stacy Wolf The book analyzes the role of female characters in musical theater and tracks the evolution of women's representation on Broadway from the 1950s to the present.
Strike Up the Band: A New History of Musical Theatre by Scott Miller A chronological examination of musical theater traces the form's evolution through analysis of significant productions, cultural movements, and artistic innovations.
On Broadway: Art and Commerce on the Great White Way by Steven Adler The text presents an inside look at the business operations, artistic decisions, and production processes that bring Broadway musicals from concept to stage.
Our Musicals, Ourselves by John Bush Jones The text examines American musicals as reflections of U.S. social history, connecting shows to specific decades and historical events from the 1920s through 2001.
Changed for Good: A Feminist History of the Broadway Musical by Stacy Wolf The book analyzes the role of female characters in musical theater and tracks the evolution of women's representation on Broadway from the 1950s to the present.
Strike Up the Band: A New History of Musical Theatre by Scott Miller A chronological examination of musical theater traces the form's evolution through analysis of significant productions, cultural movements, and artistic innovations.
On Broadway: Art and Commerce on the Great White Way by Steven Adler The text presents an inside look at the business operations, artistic decisions, and production processes that bring Broadway musicals from concept to stage.
🤔 Interesting facts
🎭 Author Gerald Bordman wrote several definitive reference works on American theater, including "The Oxford Companion to American Theatre" and "American Musical Theatre: A Chronicle."
🎪 The book begins with coverage of Adonis (1884), which is considered one of the first modern American musical comedies and starred the popular Dixey sisters.
🎵 The work traces the evolution of musical comedy from light entertainment and variety shows to more complex narrative forms, culminating with groundbreaking shows like Dreamgirls in the 1980s.
🌟 Many forgotten or overlooked shows are documented alongside famous productions, providing a comprehensive view of nearly 100 years of American musical theater development.
🎬 The book details how musical comedy emerged as a distinctly American art form, separate from European operetta and other musical theater traditions, with its own unique characteristics and conventions.