📖 Overview
Surviving Saskatoon follows the story of David Day, a Canadian journalist who investigates a case of wrongful conviction in Saskatchewan. The graphic novel format combines journalism with personal memoir as the author pieces together the truth behind a murder case from the 1960s.
Collier structures the narrative through a mix of interviews, archival materials, and his own experiences in Saskatoon while researching the story. The black and white illustrations capture both the stark prairie landscape and the complex human elements of the investigation.
The work focuses on the intersection of memory, justice, and the lasting impact of systemic failures in Canada's legal system. Through one specific case, the book examines broader questions about truth, accountability, and the possibility of redemption.
👀 Reviews
There are not enough internet reviews to create a summary of this book. Instead, here is a summary of reviews of David Collier's overall work:
Academic readers view Collier's methodological work as practical and instructive for conducting qualitative research. His texts are frequently cited in political science dissertations and research papers.
What readers liked:
- Clear explanations of complex methodological concepts
- Useful frameworks for designing case studies
- Detailed examples from real research
- Systematic approach to qualitative analysis
What readers disliked:
- Dense academic writing style
- Heavy focus on Latin American examples
- Some concepts need more concrete examples
- High price of academic texts
On Google Scholar, "Shaping the Political Arena" has over 3,000 citations. His methodological articles in academic journals regularly receive 100+ citations. On Amazon, his books average 4.3/5 stars from academic readers, though review volumes are low (typically 5-15 reviews per book). Students particularly note the utility of his process tracing methods for their own research.
A PhD student reviewer noted: "Collier provides clear tools for doing qualitative research right, even if the prose is sometimes dry."
📚 Similar books
Blankets by Craig Thompson
A graphic memoir chronicles a Midwestern coming-of-age story through stark black and white illustrations of family relationships, faith, and first love.
Essex County by Jeff Lemire This graphic novel trilogy captures life in rural Ontario through interconnected stories of hockey players, farmers, and nurses across generations.
Berlin by Jason Lutes A historical graphic novel details the lives of ordinary citizens in Germany between World Wars through precise line work and documentary-style storytelling.
Louis Riel: A Comic-Strip Biography by Chester Brown This biographical work uses minimal art and historical research to present the story of the Métis leader and the Red River Rebellion in Canadian history.
The Photographer by Emmanuel Guibert A mixed-media narrative combines photography and illustrations to document a journey through Afghanistan with Doctors Without Borders.
Essex County by Jeff Lemire This graphic novel trilogy captures life in rural Ontario through interconnected stories of hockey players, farmers, and nurses across generations.
Berlin by Jason Lutes A historical graphic novel details the lives of ordinary citizens in Germany between World Wars through precise line work and documentary-style storytelling.
Louis Riel: A Comic-Strip Biography by Chester Brown This biographical work uses minimal art and historical research to present the story of the Métis leader and the Red River Rebellion in Canadian history.
The Photographer by Emmanuel Guibert A mixed-media narrative combines photography and illustrations to document a journey through Afghanistan with Doctors Without Borders.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌟 David Collier illustrated this graphic novel using his signature black-and-white ink wash style, creating a stark, documentary-like feel that matches the serious subject matter.
🍁 The book explores the death of David Milgaard, who spent 23 years in prison for a murder he didn't commit - one of Canada's most notorious cases of wrongful conviction.
📚 Collier spent considerable time in Saskatoon researching the case, interviewing locals and visiting key locations to ensure accuracy in both his illustrations and storytelling.
⚖️ The real killer, Larry Fisher, was finally identified through DNA evidence in 1997, leading to Milgaard's exoneration and a $10 million compensation settlement.
🎨 The work is considered part of a larger movement in Canadian comics that tackles serious social issues through the graphic novel format, helping establish comics as a legitimate medium for journalism and documentary.