Wedlocked: The Perils of Marriage Equality

In Wedlocked, legal scholar Katherine Franke examines marriage rights through two parallel historical lenses: the experiences of newly emancipated Black Americans in the Reconstruction era and the contemporary LGBTQ+ marriage equality movement. She draws connections between these two watershed moments in American civil rights history to analyze the complex relationship between legal freedom and lived reality. The book chronicles how freed slaves sought marriage rights as a path to citizenship and dignity, while documenting the backlash and new forms of control they faced from both government institutions and society at large. Franke then shifts to modern times, exploring similar patterns in the wake of marriage equality victories for same-sex couples. Through extensive research and legal analysis, Franke raises questions about whether marriage equality delivers on its promises of true liberation and social acceptance. She examines how the right to marry can sometimes come with unexpected constraints and regulatory oversight from the state. At its core, this work challenges readers to look beyond simple narratives of progress and consider how expanded rights can paradoxically create new forms of vulnerability and control. The parallel histories illuminate enduring tensions between legal equality and substantive freedom in American society.

Readers value Franke's critical examination of marriage equality's limitations and unintended consequences. Many appreciate the historical parallels drawn between post-Civil War marriage rights for freed slaves and contemporary LGBTQ+ marriage equality. Positive reviews highlight the book's analysis of how marriage can reinforce state control and economic inequality. Several readers note its importance for questioning whether marriage should be the primary goal of LGBTQ+ advocacy. Critics find the academic writing style dense and inaccessible. Some readers disagree with Franke's skepticism toward marriage equality, viewing it as dismissive of hard-won LGBTQ+ rights. A few reviews mention repetitive arguments. Ratings: Goodreads: 3.9/5 (89 ratings) Amazon: 4.2/5 (12 reviews) From a Goodreads review: "A needed critique of how marriage equality can actually limit rights and recognition for diverse family structures." From an Amazon review: "Makes important points but gets bogged down in academic language that limits its reach to general readers."

Against Equality: Queer Revolution, Not Mere Inclusion by Ryan Conrad The text examines how marriage equality campaigns align with neoliberal politics and questions whether same-sex marriage serves the broader LGBTQ+ community's needs.

The Trouble with Marriage: Feminists Confront Law and Violence in India by Srimati Basu This analysis explores marriage as an institution that can perpetuate gender inequalities and state control while examining legal reforms and their limitations.

Normal Life: Administrative Violence, Critical Trans Politics, and the Limits of Law by Dean Spade The book critiques legal equality strategies and examines how administrative systems maintain power structures that affect marginalized communities.

That's Revolting!: Queer Strategies for Resisting Assimilation by Mattilda Bernstein Sycamore This collection presents radical perspectives on marriage equality and critiques mainstream LGBTQ+ politics that emphasize assimilation into heteronormative institutions.

The Gay Revolution: The Story of the Struggle by Lillian Faderman The text traces the evolution of LGBTQ+ rights movements and examines the tensions between radical change and institutional acceptance within these movements.

🔹 Katherine Franke drew parallels between marriage equality for same-sex couples and the right to marry granted to formerly enslaved people after the Civil War, examining how both groups faced unexpected legal complications after winning marriage rights. 🔹 The book's title "Wedlocked" is a play on words that references both marriage and the concept of being trapped, highlighting Franke's argument that marriage rights can sometimes function as a double-edged sword. 🔹 The author serves as the Director of the Center for Gender and Sexuality Law at Columbia Law School and founded the school's Gender Justice Advocacy Project. 🔹 The book challenges the widespread assumption that marriage equality is an unqualified victory, exploring how marriage rights can sometimes lead to the loss of other legal protections and benefits previously available to unmarried couples. 🔹 Through historical research, Franke uncovered numerous cases where newly freed slaves' marriages were used against them, such as when their spouses' debts became their legal responsibility – a warning about potential unintended consequences of marriage rights.