📖 Overview
Science Education as Conceptual Change examines how students learn scientific concepts and explores the cognitive mechanisms behind conceptual development. The book draws on research in cognitive science, developmental psychology, and science education.
Carey presents case studies of students learning fundamental scientific concepts like matter, life, and force. She analyzes the barriers students face when their intuitive conceptual frameworks conflict with scientific understanding.
The text outlines instructional approaches and teaching strategies informed by theories of conceptual change. The research findings point to ways educators can help students undergo transformations in their mental models and develop more sophisticated scientific thinking.
The work contributes to ongoing debates about science education reform and cognitive development theory. Carey's analysis suggests learning science requires more than acquiring facts - it demands restructuring of existing knowledge systems.
👀 Reviews
There are not enough internet reviews to create a summary of this book. Instead, here is a summary of reviews of Susan Carey's overall work:
Readers of Carey's academic works, particularly "The Origin of Concepts," appreciate her detailed research methodology and thorough exploration of cognitive development. Multiple reviewers on Google Scholar cite her clear explanations of complex developmental processes and comprehensive literature reviews.
Readers value:
- Detailed empirical evidence supporting theoretical claims
- Clear connections between infant cognition and later concept development
- Practical applications for education and child development
Common criticisms:
- Dense technical language makes content inaccessible to non-specialists
- Some sections require extensive background knowledge in cognitive psychology
- Limited practical examples for classroom application
Ratings:
Goodreads - "The Origin of Concepts" (3.93/5 from 43 ratings)
Amazon - "The Origin of Concepts" (4.3/5 from 12 reviews)
One professor notes: "Complex but rewarding reading for serious students of cognitive development." A graduate student reviewer states: "Would benefit from more real-world examples to illustrate theoretical points."
📚 Similar books
How Students Learn: Science in the Classroom by National Research Council
Presents research-based strategies for teaching science through conceptual understanding and addressing student misconceptions in K-12 education.
Making Sense of Secondary Science by Rosalind Driver, Ann Squires, Peter Rushworth, and Valerie Wood-Robinson Documents common student alternative conceptions in science and provides frameworks for supporting conceptual transformation.
Constructing Scientific Understanding through Contextual Teaching by William W. Cobern Examines the intersection of students' existing knowledge structures with scientific concepts and presents methods for bridging these knowledge domains.
The Construction of Scientific Knowledge in School Classrooms by Derek Edwards and Neil Mercer Analyzes classroom discourse and interactions that facilitate the transformation of students' understanding from everyday concepts to scientific ones.
Learning and Understanding: Improving Advanced Study of Mathematics and Science in U.S. High Schools by National Research Council Explores cognitive research on how students develop advanced scientific understanding and provides evidence-based recommendations for instruction.
Making Sense of Secondary Science by Rosalind Driver, Ann Squires, Peter Rushworth, and Valerie Wood-Robinson Documents common student alternative conceptions in science and provides frameworks for supporting conceptual transformation.
Constructing Scientific Understanding through Contextual Teaching by William W. Cobern Examines the intersection of students' existing knowledge structures with scientific concepts and presents methods for bridging these knowledge domains.
The Construction of Scientific Knowledge in School Classrooms by Derek Edwards and Neil Mercer Analyzes classroom discourse and interactions that facilitate the transformation of students' understanding from everyday concepts to scientific ones.
Learning and Understanding: Improving Advanced Study of Mathematics and Science in U.S. High Schools by National Research Council Explores cognitive research on how students develop advanced scientific understanding and provides evidence-based recommendations for instruction.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔍 Susan Carey's research revolutionized our understanding of how children develop scientific thinking, showing that even preschoolers engage in theory-building similar to scientists.
🧠 The book challenges Piaget's stage theory by demonstrating that young children are capable of complex conceptual change rather than being limited by developmental stages.
📚 Carey's work bridges cognitive psychology and science education, introducing the term "bootstrap learning" to explain how learners use existing concepts to grasp new, more complex ideas.
🎓 The author earned her Ph.D. under renowned cognitive psychologist Roger Brown at Harvard, where she later became the first woman to receive tenure in the Psychology Department.
🔬 The book's framework has influenced science curriculum development worldwide, particularly in helping educators understand why certain scientific concepts (like the particle nature of matter) are difficult for students to grasp.