Epicureans and Atheists in France, 1650-1729

This work examines atheist and Epicurean philosophy in France during a pivotal period spanning 1650-1729. The text focuses on how religious authorities and apologists inadvertently spread knowledge of atheistic ideas through their attempts to refute them. Kors analyzes writings from Catholic theologians, Protestant thinkers, and secular philosophers to trace the evolution of atheistic thought. The documentation reveals how defenders of Christianity preserved and transmitted the very doctrines they aimed to discredit. The research reconstructs theological debates and philosophical dialogues that occurred in salons, universities, and published works across late 17th century France. Major figures including Pierre Bayle, Nicolas Malebranche, and Pierre Gassendi feature prominently in the historical narrative. The book challenges conventional views about the origins and spread of atheism in pre-Enlightenment Europe, demonstrating how orthodox attempts to defend religion played a crucial role in developing modern secular thought. This research has implications for understanding the complex relationship between religious apologetics and the growth of skepticism.

Readers note the book's thorough examination of religious and philosophical debates in 17th century France. Several academic reviewers appreciate Kors' demonstration that Catholic theologians inadvertently strengthened atheist arguments while trying to refute Protestant theology. Positives: - Detailed archival research into previously unexplored texts - Clear explanation of complex theological arguments - Strong citations and documentation Negatives: - Dense academic writing style that some find difficult to follow - High price point limits accessibility - Some sections become repetitive Limited review data available online: Goodreads: 4.25/5 (4 ratings, 0 written reviews) Amazon: No reviews Google Books: No reviews The book is primarily discussed in academic journals rather than consumer review sites. Religious Studies Review called it "meticulously researched" while The American Historical Review praised its "ambitious intellectual reconstruction." One historian critiqued its "narrow focus on elite theological debates."

The Radical Enlightenment by Jonathan Israel This work examines the underground networks of radical philosophers and thinkers who challenged religious orthodoxy in early modern Europe.

The Forbidden Best-Sellers of Pre-Revolutionary France by Robert Darnton The book uncovers the clandestine trade in atheistic, materialistic, and philosophical texts in 18th century France through analysis of bookseller records and police reports.

Heterodoxy in Early Modern Science and Religion by John Brooke and Ian Maclean This study explores the intersection of scientific thinking and religious dissent in Europe from 1500-1750 through examination of key philosophical and theological debates.

Reading Underground by Jean-Pierre Cavaillé The text maps the circulation of libertine and atheistic manuscripts in 17th century France through analysis of correspondence and legal documents.

The French Enlightenment and Its Others by David Allen Harvey This work traces how French intellectual culture developed through engagement with non-European philosophies and rejection of traditional Christian thought.

🔹 Although Epicureanism was widely considered synonymous with atheism in 17th-century France, author Alan Charles Kors reveals that it was actually religious theologians who inadvertently spread atheistic ideas while attempting to refute them. 🔹 The book challenges the common belief that atheism emerged from radical philosophy, showing instead that it developed largely from theological debates within the Catholic Church. 🔹 Many of the period's most influential religious thinkers unintentionally created sophisticated atheistic arguments by attempting to imagine and then defeat potential challenges to faith. 🔹 The work was awarded the 2017 David Pinkney Prize by the Society for French Historical Studies for the best book on French history published by a North American scholar. 🔹 Author Alan Charles Kors is Professor Emeritus of History at the University of Pennsylvania and has dedicated over four decades to studying the intellectual history of early modern Europe.