📖 Overview
The Five Chinese Brothers (1938) follows five identical brothers in Imperial China who each possess an extraordinary physical ability. The brothers live with their mother by the sea, where the first brother works as a fisherman using his unique talent to catch rare fish.
A series of events leads to the first brother being accused of a crime he did not commit. What follows is a tale of loyalty and ingenuity as the brothers work together to overcome mounting challenges using their individual gifts.
This retelling of a Chinese folk tale weaves together elements of family bonds, justice, and the power of individual strengths working in harmony. The story demonstrates how seemingly impossible situations can be overcome through cooperation and clever problem-solving.
👀 Reviews
Most readers remember this book fondly from their childhood, noting its memorable story structure and distinctive yellow-and-blue illustrations. On Goodreads, it maintains a 4.1/5 rating from over 23,000 ratings.
Readers appreciate:
- The repetitive storytelling pattern that helps children follow along
- The message about brotherhood and loyalty
- The unique visual style with its limited color palette
- The clever resolution to each brother's predicament
Common criticisms include:
- Stereotypical depictions of Chinese characters with yellow skin and slanted eyes
- Cultural insensitivity in the illustrations
- Potential confusion between this version and the original folk tale
Amazon reviews average 4.7/5 from 500+ ratings, with many parents noting their children request repeated readings. Several teachers mention using it in classrooms, though some express hesitation about its dated racial representations.
A notable number of reviewers suggest the 1938 publication needs updating for modern sensibilities while maintaining the core story.
📚 Similar books
The Seven Chinese Sisters by Kathy Tucker
Seven sisters with distinct abilities work together to rescue their youngest sibling from a dragon.
One Grain of Rice: A Mathematical Folktale by Demi A clever girl uses mathematics to outsmart a raja and feed her village through multiplying grains of rice.
The Empty Pot by Demi A boy's honesty in failing to grow the Emperor's seeds leads to an unexpected outcome in this Chinese folktale.
The Great Race: The Story of the Chinese Zodiac by Dawn Casey The tale explains how thirteen animals competed in a race to determine their place in the Chinese zodiac calendar.
The Magic Paintbrush by Julia Donaldson A poor boy receives a paintbrush that brings his paintings to life and uses it to help his village.
One Grain of Rice: A Mathematical Folktale by Demi A clever girl uses mathematics to outsmart a raja and feed her village through multiplying grains of rice.
The Empty Pot by Demi A boy's honesty in failing to grow the Emperor's seeds leads to an unexpected outcome in this Chinese folktale.
The Great Race: The Story of the Chinese Zodiac by Dawn Casey The tale explains how thirteen animals competed in a race to determine their place in the Chinese zodiac calendar.
The Magic Paintbrush by Julia Donaldson A poor boy receives a paintbrush that brings his paintings to life and uses it to help his village.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔸 The story is based on an ancient Chinese folk tale called "Ten Brothers," which dates back to the Qing Dynasty and originally featured ten siblings instead of five.
🔸 Illustrator Kurt Wiese spent several years living in China as a prisoner of war during World War I, which greatly influenced his artistic style and understanding of Asian culture.
🔸 Author Claire Huchet Bishop was born in Switzerland and began her career by founding France's first children's library in 1924 before moving to the United States.
🔸 The book faced controversy in later years due to its depiction of Chinese characters, leading some libraries to remove it from their collections in the 1970s and 1980s.
🔸 Despite mixed modern reception, the book won the Lewis Carroll Shelf Award in 1959, an honor given to books deemed to belong "on the same shelf" as Alice in Wonderland.