Book
The Point Is To Change It: Poetry and Criticism in the Continuing Present
📖 Overview
The Point Is To Change It examines poetry and literary criticism through the lens of cultural and historical materialism. McGann analyzes works from the Romantic period through contemporary times while challenging traditional approaches to literary scholarship.
The book combines close readings of specific poems with broader theoretical arguments about interpretation and criticism. McGann draws on figures like William Morris and William Blake to demonstrate how poetic works engage with social and political realities.
Through case studies and theoretical discussions, McGann explores how digital technologies and new media are transforming literary studies and textual scholarship. The work addresses key questions about poetry's role in cultural memory and social change.
The book argues for a form of criticism that goes beyond purely aesthetic considerations to examine literature's relationship to material conditions and social transformation. McGann's analysis suggests that poetry and criticism must be understood as active forces in shaping cultural consciousness rather than passive objects of study.
👀 Reviews
This book appears to have very limited reader reviews available online, with no reviews on Amazon and only 2 ratings (but no written reviews) on Goodreads.
What readers appreciated:
- Academic analysis of poetry criticism's role in literary studies
- Examination of digital humanities impact on poetry scholarship
Reader criticisms:
- Dense academic writing style that limits accessibility
- Assumes significant prior knowledge of critical theory
- Some arguments could be more clearly presented
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.5/5 (2 ratings, 0 written reviews)
Amazon: No reviews
Google Books: No reviews
Note: Due to the specialized academic nature of this work and limited public reviews, this summary relies on a very small sample of reader feedback. The book appears to be primarily discussed in academic contexts rather than consumer review platforms.
📚 Similar books
The Figure of Echo by John Holland
This study explores the relationship between poetic forms and critical interpretation through historical and contemporary examples.
Radical Artifice by Marjorie Perloff The text examines avant-garde poetry's engagement with language theory and cultural critique in the post-modern era.
The Resistance to Poetry by James Longenbach This work investigates poetry's capacity for meaning-making through close readings of canonical and contemporary poems.
The Art of Poetry by Shira Wolosky The book connects poetic analysis with theoretical frameworks through examination of form, structure, and historical context.
Theory of the Lyric by Jonathan Culler This analysis presents a systematic approach to understanding lyric poetry through historical development and critical theory.
Radical Artifice by Marjorie Perloff The text examines avant-garde poetry's engagement with language theory and cultural critique in the post-modern era.
The Resistance to Poetry by James Longenbach This work investigates poetry's capacity for meaning-making through close readings of canonical and contemporary poems.
The Art of Poetry by Shira Wolosky The book connects poetic analysis with theoretical frameworks through examination of form, structure, and historical context.
Theory of the Lyric by Jonathan Culler This analysis presents a systematic approach to understanding lyric poetry through historical development and critical theory.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔹 Jerome McGann coined the term "social text," which revolutionized textual criticism by emphasizing how social and material conditions influence literary works' meanings.
📚 The book's title comes from Karl Marx's famous "Theses on Feuerbach," specifically the line "Philosophers have only interpreted the world in various ways; the point is to change it."
🎯 McGann developed the groundbreaking NINES project (Networked Infrastructure for Nineteenth-century Electronic Scholarship), one of the first major digital humanities initiatives.
✍️ The author has been a pioneer in digital humanities since the 1990s, arguing that digital tools can transform how we understand and analyze poetry and literature.
🏆 McGann received the Modern Language Association's James Russell Lowell Prize for his work "The Textual Condition," which laid the groundwork for many ideas explored in "The Point Is To Change It."