A Scrap of Paper: Breaking and Making International Law during the Great War

A Scrap of Paper examines how international law shaped and was shaped by World War I, focusing on the major powers' use and interpretation of legal frameworks during the conflict. The book analyzes Germany's invasion of Belgium in 1914 and the subsequent legal debates that emerged around neutrality, civilian rights, and military necessity. The study draws from extensive archival research across multiple countries, revealing how diplomats, politicians, and military leaders engaged with international law throughout the war years. Hull investigates key legal controversies including submarine warfare, blockades, occupation policies, and the treatment of civilians in occupied territories. The text reconstructs the legal arguments and counter-arguments made by both Allied and Central Powers, examining how each side justified their actions through competing interpretations of existing laws and treaties. Primary source materials include diplomatic correspondence, military documents, government records, and contemporary legal scholarship. The book demonstrates how World War I marked a critical turning point in the development and application of international law, with implications that extended well beyond the conflict itself. Through its examination of legal discourse and practice during wartime, the work raises broader questions about the relationship between law, power, and armed conflict.

Readers value Hull's detailed analysis of how international law shaped WWI decision-making and policy. Multiple reviewers note the book fills an important gap by examining legal frameworks rather than just military or political aspects. Readers appreciate: - Clear explanations of complex legal concepts - Focus on often-overlooked German legal interpretations - Extensive primary source research - Balanced treatment of all belligerent nations Common criticisms: - Dense academic writing style - Assumes substantial background knowledge - Some sections become repetitive - Limited coverage of non-European perspectives Ratings: Goodreads: 3.9/5 (26 ratings) Amazon: 4.4/5 (12 ratings) One academic reviewer on Amazon notes: "Hull presents compelling evidence that international law was not simply abandoned during WWI but actively debated and shaped by the conflict." A Goodreads reviewer critiques: "Important content but the writing can be dry and inaccessible for non-specialists."

War and Law Since 1945 by Geoffrey Best This book traces how states interpreted and applied international law in conflicts from World War II through modern warfare.

The Laws of War in International History by Stephen Neff The text examines the development of warfare regulations from ancient times through the twentieth century with focus on state practice and diplomatic relations.

The Laws of War: Constraints on Warfare in the Western World by Michael Howard, George Andreopoulos This work analyzes how Western nations created and enforced rules of combat from the Middle Ages through modern conflicts.

Law, War and Crime: War Crimes Trials and the Reinvention of International Law by Gerry Simpson The book explores how war crimes trials shaped international law and established precedents for modern military justice.

How Fighting Ends: A History of Surrender by Holger Afflerbach and Hew Strachan This volume examines surrender protocols and conventions in warfare from antiquity through the modern era, revealing the evolution of military law and custom.

🔹 Author Isabel Hull is a prominent historian at Cornell University who specializes in German history and has won multiple awards, including the prestigious Levenson Teaching Prize. 🔹 The book challenges the common view that international law was irrelevant during WWI, showing instead how legal arguments and frameworks played a crucial role in wartime decision-making. 🔹 The title "A Scrap of Paper" refers to German Chancellor Bethmann Hollweg's infamous dismissal of the 1839 Treaty of London, which guaranteed Belgian neutrality, as merely a "scrap of paper." 🔹 This was the first major war where belligerent nations had to consider the implications of new technologies like submarines, aerial warfare, and chemical weapons within existing international law. 🔹 The book won the 2015 Bancroft Prize, one of the most prestigious awards in American historical writing, awarded annually by Columbia University.