📖 Overview
A Behanding in Spokane is Martin McDonagh's first play set in America. The dark comedy centers on Carmichael, a man searching for his missing left hand after it was severed in a brutal incident decades ago.
The story takes place in a rundown hotel room where Carmichael encounters a young couple attempting to sell him what they claim is his long-lost hand. The single-location setting creates a pressure cooker atmosphere as tensions rise between the characters.
The play incorporates McDonagh's signature blend of violence, absurdist humor, and morally ambiguous characters. Through its examination of obsession, truth, and human connection, the work continues McDonagh's exploration of revenge and the lasting impacts of trauma.
👀 Reviews
Readers consider this play less impactful than McDonagh's earlier works. The dark humor and punchy dialogue receive praise, with reviewers noting it captures McDonagh's signature style of blending comedy with violence.
Likes:
- Fast-paced scenes that maintain tension
- Christopher Walken's character (in stage version)
- Absurdist elements and unexpected twists
Dislikes:
- Plot stretches believability
- Less depth compared to McDonagh's other plays
- Some find the racial elements forced or uncomfortable
- Ending feels unsatisfying to many readers
Review Scores:
Goodreads: 3.5/5 (300+ ratings)
Amazon: 4.1/5 (15 ratings)
Several readers note it works better as a performed play than read text. One Goodreads reviewer wrote: "The dialogue crackles but the story itself feels thin." Multiple reviews suggest it's worth reading for McDonagh fans but not an ideal introduction to his work.
📚 Similar books
True West by Sam Shepard
This dark comedy about two brothers locked in psychological warfare contains similar themes of violence, identity, and twisted humor in an American setting.
The Lieutenant of Inishmore by Martin McDonagh The play follows an Irish terrorist seeking revenge for his dead cat through escalating cycles of absurd violence and dark humor.
American Buffalo by David Mamet Three small-time crooks plan a heist in this play that shares the same cramped setting, desperate characters, and raw dialogue style.
Killer Joe by Tracy Letts A dysfunctional family hires a contract killer, leading to a violent chain of events that mirrors the dark comedy and moral ambiguity found in Behanding.
The Pillowman by Martin McDonagh This play about a writer being interrogated for murders that mirror his stories captures the same mix of brutality, dark humor, and psychological tension.
The Lieutenant of Inishmore by Martin McDonagh The play follows an Irish terrorist seeking revenge for his dead cat through escalating cycles of absurd violence and dark humor.
American Buffalo by David Mamet Three small-time crooks plan a heist in this play that shares the same cramped setting, desperate characters, and raw dialogue style.
Killer Joe by Tracy Letts A dysfunctional family hires a contract killer, leading to a violent chain of events that mirrors the dark comedy and moral ambiguity found in Behanding.
The Pillowman by Martin McDonagh This play about a writer being interrogated for murders that mirror his stories captures the same mix of brutality, dark humor, and psychological tension.
🤔 Interesting facts
📚 "A Behanding in Spokane" marked Martin McDonagh's first play set in America, after previously setting his works in Ireland and England.
🎭 Despite its dark themes, the play was written as a black comedy and premiered on Broadway in 2010 with Christopher Walken in the lead role as Carmichael.
🏆 Christopher Walken received a Tony Award nomination for Best Actor for his portrayal of Carmichael, the one-handed protagonist searching for his missing appendage.
✍️ McDonagh wrote the role of Carmichael specifically with Christopher Walken in mind, tailoring the character's peculiarities to match Walken's distinctive acting style.
🌟 The play's central premise was inspired by real-life cases of body part reattachment, though McDonagh took creative liberties with the medical possibilities for dramatic effect.