Book
To Live as Brothers: Southeast Sumatra in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries
📖 Overview
To Live as Brothers examines the social, political and economic relationships between different ethnic groups in southeast Sumatra during the 17th and 18th centuries. The book focuses on the Jambi and Palembang sultanates and their interactions with Dutch colonial powers, Chinese traders, and indigenous peoples.
Based on Dutch East India Company records and local Malay texts, the work reconstructs daily life, trade networks, and power dynamics in this pivotal region. Watson Andaya documents how coastal sultanates maintained authority over inland regions and managed complex diplomatic relationships with foreign merchants.
Through examination of marriage alliances, trade agreements, and cultural exchange, the book reveals patterns of cooperation and conflict between diverse populations. The changing dynamics between upriver and downriver communities take center stage in this historical analysis.
The work provides key insights into how Southeast Asian societies navigated cultural differences and competing interests during a period of increasing European colonial influence. Watson Andaya's research challenges simplified narratives about power relations in colonial-era maritime Southeast Asia.
👀 Reviews
This appears to be an academic text with limited public reader reviews available online. The few academic reviews praise Andaya's research depth into Southeast Sumatran social and economic networks during the Dutch colonial period. Several readers note the book fills gaps in Indonesian historiography.
Likes:
- Thorough use of Dutch East India Company archives
- Analysis of pepper trade networks
- Coverage of local sultanates and power structures
- Maps and original source material
Dislikes:
- Dense academic writing style
- Limited coverage of ordinary people's lives
- High cost of hardcover edition
Available Ratings:
Goodreads: No ratings
Google Books: No ratings
WorldCat: No public reviews
JSTOR: 3 academic journal reviews (not scored)
The book appears primarily used in university courses and cited in academic works rather than read by general audiences. Public reviews and ratings are scarce due to its specialized academic nature.
📚 Similar books
The Age of Commerce in Southeast Asia by Anthony Reid
An examination of Southeast Asian trade networks, cultural exchange, and social transformation during the pivotal period of 1450-1680.
Merchant Kings: When Companies Ruled the World by Stephen R. Bown The exploration of European trading companies' influence on Southeast Asian societies and their role in shaping colonial power structures.
Muslim Rulers and Rebels by Thomas M. McKenna A study of power relations between Islamic communities and colonial authorities in the southern Philippines from the 16th to 20th centuries.
The Making of Southeast Asia by Amitav Acharya The analysis of historical patterns in Southeast Asian international relations and regional identity formation from pre-colonial times through independence.
Southeast Asia in the Age of Commerce 1450-1680: The Lands Below the Winds by Barbara Watson Andaya and Leonard Y. Andaya The investigation of maritime trade, political systems, and social structures in pre-colonial Southeast Asian coastal regions.
Merchant Kings: When Companies Ruled the World by Stephen R. Bown The exploration of European trading companies' influence on Southeast Asian societies and their role in shaping colonial power structures.
Muslim Rulers and Rebels by Thomas M. McKenna A study of power relations between Islamic communities and colonial authorities in the southern Philippines from the 16th to 20th centuries.
The Making of Southeast Asia by Amitav Acharya The analysis of historical patterns in Southeast Asian international relations and regional identity formation from pre-colonial times through independence.
Southeast Asia in the Age of Commerce 1450-1680: The Lands Below the Winds by Barbara Watson Andaya and Leonard Y. Andaya The investigation of maritime trade, political systems, and social structures in pre-colonial Southeast Asian coastal regions.
🤔 Interesting facts
🌿 The book explores how pepper cultivation transformed Southeast Sumatra's economy and society, turning previously isolated communities into major players in international trade.
🏛️ Barbara Watson Andaya is considered one of the foremost historians of Southeast Asia and has taught at the University of Hawaii since 1994. She was the first female President of the American Association of Asian Studies.
🗺️ The region covered in the book, Jambi and Palembang, was once home to the powerful Srivijaya Empire (7th-14th centuries), which controlled the vital Malacca Straits trading route.
👥 The book reveals how Dutch colonial policies inadvertently strengthened local kinship networks and traditional power structures rather than weakening them as intended.
🤝 The author demonstrates how maritime Southeast Asian societies maintained their cultural identity and autonomy while adapting to new economic opportunities and political pressures from European traders.