Book
Aspect: An Introduction to the Study of Verbal Aspect and Related Problems
📖 Overview
Bernard Comrie's Aspect examines the linguistic concept of verbal aspect across languages, focusing on how grammar systems express distinctions in the temporal structure of events. The book establishes core terminology and frameworks for analyzing aspectual features like perfective, imperfective, and progressive forms.
Through analysis of data from multiple language families, Comrie demonstrates how different languages encode aspect through morphology, syntax, and lexical means. The work presents detailed case studies of aspect in Russian, English, Chinese, and other languages to illustrate key theoretical points.
The text also addresses related phenomena like tense, mood, and aktionsart, clarifying their relationships to aspect while maintaining focus on its distinct properties. The analysis extends to interactions between aspect and other grammatical categories.
This foundational work in linguistic theory offers insights into how human languages conceptualize and grammaticalize the temporal structure of events and situations. The cross-linguistic approach reveals both universal patterns and cultural variation in how speakers view and describe actions through time.
👀 Reviews
Students and linguists who have read this work value its clear explanations of complex aspectual concepts. The straightforward writing style and logical organization help readers grasp challenging grammatical theory.
Readers appreciate the cross-linguistic examples from multiple language families. Several reviewers note the book provides a strong foundation for understanding aspect in different languages.
Common criticisms include:
- Too much focus on Slavic languages
- Some explanations are overly simplistic
- Lack of exercises or practice materials
- Dated examples and research (published 1976)
Ratings:
Goodreads: 4.17/5 (47 ratings)
Amazon: 4.6/5 (5 ratings)
One linguistics graduate student wrote: "Clear and thorough introduction to verbal aspect. The explanations clicked for me in a way other texts didn't."
A reviewer criticized: "The Slavic bias limits its usefulness for studying aspect in non-Indo-European languages."
📚 Similar books
Tense by Östen Dahl
The analysis of tense systems across languages presents a theoretical framework that complements Comrie's aspectual studies.
Temporality in Discourse by Suzanne Fleischman This work connects verbal aspect to broader discourse functions through cross-linguistic data and historical development patterns.
Time and the Verb by Robert I. Binnick The comprehensive examination of tense, aspect, and modality systems provides a natural extension to Comrie's foundational work.
The Parameter of Aspect by Carlota S. Smith The two-component theory of aspect builds upon Comrie's framework while incorporating situation types and viewpoint aspects.
Mood and Modality by F.R. Palmer This systematic analysis of grammatical categories parallels Comrie's approach while focusing on modal systems across languages.
Temporality in Discourse by Suzanne Fleischman This work connects verbal aspect to broader discourse functions through cross-linguistic data and historical development patterns.
Time and the Verb by Robert I. Binnick The comprehensive examination of tense, aspect, and modality systems provides a natural extension to Comrie's foundational work.
The Parameter of Aspect by Carlota S. Smith The two-component theory of aspect builds upon Comrie's framework while incorporating situation types and viewpoint aspects.
Mood and Modality by F.R. Palmer This systematic analysis of grammatical categories parallels Comrie's approach while focusing on modal systems across languages.
🤔 Interesting facts
🔹 Bernard Comrie's work on aspect has been cited over 8,000 times and is considered the foundational text for modern linguistic study of verbal aspect, despite being published in 1976.
🔹 The book was the first to systematically compare how different languages handle verbal aspect, examining examples from Russian, English, Arabic, Chinese, and dozens of other languages.
🔹 The distinction between perfective and imperfective aspect that Comrie discusses in detail was later found to be crucial in developing more accurate machine translation systems.
🔹 While teaching at the University of Southern California, Comrie used early drafts of this book to train field linguists who went on to document aspect systems in previously unstudied languages.
🔹 The book's framework for understanding aspect has been applied beyond linguistics to fields like cognitive psychology, where researchers use it to study how different languages might influence speakers' perception of time and events.