📖 Overview
The Church Women Want presents essays and perspectives from Catholic women scholars, theologians, and religious leaders examining their roles and experiences within the Catholic Church. The collection stems from a 2001 conference at Catholic University of America where women gathered to discuss reform, inclusion, and the future of their faith.
Editor Elizabeth A. Johnson brings together diverse voices addressing topics from ministry and leadership to sexuality, ordination, and sacred traditions. Contributors analyze church teachings, share personal narratives, and propose paths forward for greater participation of women in church life and governance.
The essays tackle complex theological and practical questions about gender, power, and institutional change within one of the world's largest religious institutions. Through research, reflection and dialogue, the authors explore what an authentically inclusive Catholic Church could look like.
This collection captures a pivotal moment in the ongoing conversation about women's place in Catholicism, highlighting both persistent challenges and hopeful possibilities for transformation. The work raises fundamental questions about tradition, authority, and the essential role of women's voices in shaping the church's future.
👀 Reviews
Readers note this is a collection of thought-provoking essays from multiple Catholic women theologians and scholars exploring various visions for the future of the Catholic Church.
Readers appreciated:
- Clear writing style accessible to non-academics
- Personal stories and experiences shared by contributors
- Balance of theological analysis with practical suggestions
- Diversity of perspectives from different women authors
Common criticisms:
- Some found certain essays too academic/theoretical
- A few readers wanted more concrete action steps
- Limited inclusion of conservative Catholic viewpoints
Ratings:
Goodreads: 3.8/5 (18 ratings)
Amazon: 4.2/5 (9 ratings)
Review quotes:
"Offers hope while acknowledging the frustrations many women feel" - Goodreads reviewer
"Important contribution to the dialogue but could have included more traditional voices" - Amazon reviewer
"The personal narratives made the theological concepts more relatable" - Goodreads reviewer
📚 Similar books
Women and Spirit: Catholic Sisters in America by Carole Rogers
Documents the impact of Catholic women religious orders in shaping American social institutions through firsthand accounts and historical records.
Beyond Patching: Faith and Feminism in the Catholic Church by Sandra Marie Schneiders Examines the intersection of feminist theology and Catholic tradition while proposing structural changes in church leadership and ministry.
Standing Before Us: Unitarian Universalist Women and Social Reform by Dorothy May Emerson Chronicles the contributions of women religious leaders who drove social reform movements from abolition to contemporary social justice initiatives.
The Emergence of Liberation Theology by Christian Smith Traces the development of liberation theology through the lens of women's participation and leadership in Latin American Catholic movements.
Catholic Does Not Equal the Vatican by Rosemary Radford Ruether Presents alternative perspectives on Catholic identity through women's experiences and theological interpretations of church doctrine.
Beyond Patching: Faith and Feminism in the Catholic Church by Sandra Marie Schneiders Examines the intersection of feminist theology and Catholic tradition while proposing structural changes in church leadership and ministry.
Standing Before Us: Unitarian Universalist Women and Social Reform by Dorothy May Emerson Chronicles the contributions of women religious leaders who drove social reform movements from abolition to contemporary social justice initiatives.
The Emergence of Liberation Theology by Christian Smith Traces the development of liberation theology through the lens of women's participation and leadership in Latin American Catholic movements.
Catholic Does Not Equal the Vatican by Rosemary Radford Ruether Presents alternative perspectives on Catholic identity through women's experiences and theological interpretations of church doctrine.
🤔 Interesting facts
📚 Author Elizabeth A. Johnson is a Distinguished Professor Emerita at Fordham University and was the first woman to receive a Ph.D. in theology from The Catholic University of America
🔍 The book emerged from a groundbreaking conference held at Fairfield University in 2001 where Catholic women scholars gathered to discuss their vision for the Church
⚜️ Despite facing criticism from some U.S. bishops for her theological work, Johnson was elected as the first woman president of the Catholic Theological Society of America
🌟 The book includes contributions from 11 different female Catholic theologians and scholars, representing diverse perspectives on women's roles in the Church
✝️ This work builds on the Second Vatican Council's call for dialogue within the Church, specifically addressing the gap between official Church teaching and women's lived experiences